Mean State

Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -93.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -90.7 -90.6 -93.7 3.09 9.18 0.996 0.752 0.704 0.891 0.938 0.798
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -89.3 -89.1 -93.7 4.54 10.9 0.717 0.672 0.702 0.928 0.812 0.763
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -101. -101. -93.6 -7.33 13.1 0.784 0.682 0.587 0.906 0.999 0.752
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -93.6 -93.4 -93.7 0.260 8.21 0.889 0.805 0.710 0.915 0.970 0.822
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -88.2 -88.1 -93.7 5.59 11.2 0.872 0.674 0.683 0.912 0.913 0.773
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -102. -102. -93.6 -8.73 15.5 0.733 0.631 0.547 0.920 0.998 0.729
CESM2_BARPA [-] -94.1 -94.0 -93.7 -0.352 8.82 0.650 0.810 0.692 0.928 0.978 0.820
CESM2_CCAM [-] -98.0 -97.8 -93.7 -4.19 10.9 0.719 0.742 0.645 0.911 0.984 0.785
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -95.1 -94.9 -93.7 -1.27 10.7 0.943 0.816 0.625 0.888 0.977 0.786
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -82.0 -81.9 -93.7 11.8 15.7 1.07 0.539 0.676 0.848 0.652 0.678
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -85.6 -85.6 -93.9 8.28 14.4 1.39 0.612 0.607 0.781 0.840 0.689
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -91.8 -91.8 -93.7 1.85 9.50 0.730 0.702 0.729 0.916 0.814 0.778
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -100. -100. -93.6 -6.32 12.2 0.645 0.705 0.627 0.924 0.919 0.760
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -98.3 -98.2 -93.7 -4.53 8.83 0.648 0.753 0.715 0.926 0.983 0.818
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -91.4 -91.3 -93.7 2.33 10.3 1.01 0.720 0.675 0.856 0.895 0.764
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -98.7 -98.6 -93.7 -4.89 13.6 0.900 0.699 0.586 0.873 0.900 0.729
ERA5_BARPA [-] -91.8 -91.6 -93.7 2.01 8.35 0.852 0.781 0.719 0.906 0.955 0.816
ERA5_CCAM [-] -88.3 -88.3 -93.7 5.41 9.77 0.648 0.677 0.760 0.915 0.898 0.802
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -99.1 -98.9 -93.7 -5.28 9.55 0.571 0.737 0.702 0.936 0.985 0.813
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -101. -101. -93.7 -7.24 11.5 0.856 0.679 0.683 0.884 0.915 0.769
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -87.4 -87.3 -93.7 6.31 13.2 1.14 0.680 0.600 0.853 0.912 0.729
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -78.2 -78.1 -93.7 15.6 17.9 0.861 0.471 0.704 0.913 0.767 0.712
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -87.8 -87.8 -93.9 6.12 10.5 0.823 0.691 0.705 0.902 0.962 0.793
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -82.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -82.9 -82.6 -82.4 -0.208 6.78 1.19 0.870 0.653 0.871 0.962 0.818
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -80.9 -80.8 -82.4 1.62 6.74 0.665 0.820 0.681 0.918 0.798 0.791
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -85.3 -85.3 -82.5 -2.75 9.33 0.431 0.830 0.560 0.946 0.988 0.801
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -83.9 -83.6 -82.4 -1.27 5.52 1.37 0.843 0.725 0.855 0.955 0.831
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -78.2 -78.1 -82.4 4.28 7.81 0.247 0.747 0.689 0.963 0.784 0.784
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -86.0 -86.0 -82.1 -3.86 9.12 0.621 0.771 0.579 0.950 0.941 0.784
CESM2_BARPA [-] -83.7 -83.3 -82.4 -0.905 5.77 0.488 0.864 0.709 0.937 0.981 0.855
CESM2_CCAM [-] -89.4 -89.2 -82.4 -6.86 8.58 0.451 0.635 0.721 0.960 0.902 0.795
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -85.5 -85.1 -82.4 -2.72 7.90 1.26 0.809 0.620 0.872 0.988 0.800
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -74.8 -74.7 -82.4 7.68 10.2 1.76 0.615 0.651 0.783 0.804 0.707
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -75.1 -75.1 -82.1 7.06 10.8 3.34 0.615 0.582 0.419 0.953 0.635
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -85.4 -85.3 -82.4 -2.88 8.49 0.492 0.783 0.602 0.943 0.820 0.766
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -89.1 -89.1 -82.5 -6.62 12.4 0.685 0.649 0.499 0.955 0.938 0.731
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -90.6 -90.2 -82.4 -7.85 9.56 0.317 0.589 0.701 0.948 0.970 0.791
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -87.6 -87.4 -82.4 -5.02 8.10 0.712 0.717 0.682 0.875 0.812 0.762
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -96.3 -96.0 -82.4 -13.7 15.5 0.647 0.403 0.613 0.893 0.990 0.712
ERA5_BARPA [-] -84.1 -83.7 -82.4 -1.33 6.70 0.318 0.856 0.662 0.948 0.976 0.838
ERA5_CCAM [-] -80.1 -79.9 -82.4 2.44 5.58 0.318 0.804 0.764 0.948 0.784 0.818
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -93.5 -93.1 -82.4 -10.7 12.5 0.352 0.490 0.655 0.945 0.983 0.756
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -95.5 -95.5 -82.4 -13.2 14.5 0.958 0.416 0.661 0.831 0.982 0.716
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -78.6 -78.3 -82.4 4.06 12.2 1.05 0.771 0.466 0.887 0.959 0.737
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -69.7 -69.6 -82.4 12.8 15.2 1.05 0.441 0.589 0.899 0.652 0.639
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -77.8 -77.8 -82.1 4.31 7.47 0.701 0.753 0.701 0.902 0.911 0.804
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -69.6
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -72.6 -72.9 -69.6 -3.31 6.89 1.30 0.768 0.731 0.832 0.788 0.763
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -73.8 -74.1 -69.6 -4.49 7.87 1.97 0.736 0.673 0.725 0.917 0.757
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -82.0 -82.0 -71.0 -11.1 13.8 2.02 0.463 0.599 0.693 0.997 0.678
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -71.8 -72.2 -69.6 -2.53 6.16 0.462 0.805 0.735 0.970 0.852 0.834
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -68.3 -68.7 -69.6 0.930 5.62 0.969 0.817 0.743 0.913 0.889 0.840
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -81.5 -81.5 -72.3 -9.18 12.3 1.71 0.521 0.575 0.779 0.999 0.705
CESM2_BARPA [-] -73.3 -73.9 -69.6 -4.27 8.16 0.359 0.739 0.662 0.977 0.931 0.775
CESM2_CCAM [-] -75.9 -76.4 -69.6 -6.76 8.50 0.490 0.638 0.725 0.969 0.992 0.818
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -74.5 -75.0 -69.6 -5.39 8.74 1.42 0.696 0.661 0.780 0.984 0.760
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -68.6 -69.2 -69.6 0.440 5.75 0.494 0.850 0.718 0.968 0.971 0.837
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -69.1 -69.1 -71.1 2.05 7.49 1.39 0.718 0.701 0.811 0.837 0.750
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -75.4 -75.8 -69.6 -6.14 9.36 1.64 0.666 0.635 0.816 0.927 0.744
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -79.3 -79.3 -71.6 -7.69 11.5 2.02 0.585 0.565 0.740 0.996 0.676
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -78.1 -78.5 -69.6 -8.91 10.1 0.359 0.551 0.742 0.977 0.952 0.778
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -76.5 -76.9 -69.6 -7.27 8.85 0.362 0.613 0.732 0.977 0.972 0.810
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -86.3 -86.0 -69.6 -16.4 18.3 0.589 0.341 0.600 0.953 0.945 0.695
ERA5_BARPA [-] -73.2 -73.6 -69.6 -4.01 7.25 1.42 0.753 0.713 0.781 0.910 0.755
ERA5_CCAM [-] -70.4 -70.8 -69.6 -1.21 4.88 0.819 0.824 0.798 0.928 0.877 0.842
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -81.9 -82.3 -69.6 -12.7 13.8 0.826 0.428 0.715 0.917 0.913 0.727
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -87.1 -87.5 -69.6 -17.9 18.8 0.882 0.303 0.690 0.909 0.919 0.696
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -69.6 -70.2 -69.6 -0.557 9.38 2.45 0.825 0.578 0.624 0.860 0.705
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -61.4 -61.7 -69.6 7.91 10.8 1.06 0.599 0.658 0.871 0.652 0.730
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -68.4 -68.4 -71.1 2.74 6.44 0.736 0.792 0.703 0.910 0.982 0.835
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -81.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -80.2 -79.8 -81.7 1.89 10.3 0.688 0.755 0.697 0.941 0.822 0.789
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -81.1 -80.6 -81.7 1.17 11.1 0.875 0.763 0.660 0.912 0.839 0.772
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -90.4 -90.4 -81.4 -9.04 15.1 1.11 0.646 0.581 0.878 0.901 0.735
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -81.8 -81.3 -81.7 0.418 9.57 0.496 0.779 0.707 0.968 0.857 0.818
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -77.3 -76.7 -81.7 5.01 12.0 0.960 0.722 0.652 0.907 0.833 0.769
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -90.7 -90.7 -82.1 -8.59 17.1 0.926 0.655 0.517 0.900 0.964 0.738
CESM2_BARPA [-] -86.5 -86.0 -81.7 -4.26 11.6 0.637 0.763 0.648 0.945 0.877 0.793
CESM2_CCAM [-] -90.5 -89.7 -81.7 -7.96 13.8 0.471 0.688 0.620 0.970 0.982 0.802
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -87.0 -86.4 -81.7 -4.69 12.7 0.832 0.753 0.622 0.902 0.903 0.775
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -76.7 -76.3 -81.7 5.41 9.99 0.471 0.716 0.754 0.970 0.769 0.786
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -79.2 -79.2 -82.6 3.47 12.0 0.497 0.727 0.654 0.968 0.686 0.749
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -84.4 -84.1 -81.7 -2.40 8.14 0.622 0.765 0.790 0.943 0.863 0.833
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -97.5 -97.5 -82.0 -15.5 19.0 0.931 0.490 0.619 0.901 0.969 0.733
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -85.7 -85.3 -81.7 -3.54 8.95 0.873 0.775 0.739 0.922 0.923 0.829
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -79.3 -78.9 -81.7 2.81 9.06 0.537 0.773 0.726 0.965 0.912 0.831
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -85.1 -84.9 -81.7 -3.12 15.7 0.537 0.748 0.517 0.965 0.830 0.739
ERA5_BARPA [-] -82.0 -81.6 -81.7 0.127 9.43 0.680 0.780 0.707 0.930 0.850 0.804
ERA5_CCAM [-] -76.2 -75.9 -81.7 5.82 8.55 0.445 0.713 0.837 0.971 0.879 0.849
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -89.3 -88.9 -81.7 -7.15 11.4 0.571 0.697 0.709 0.950 0.920 0.806
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -95.8 -95.1 -81.7 -13.4 15.7 0.504 0.538 0.715 0.966 0.868 0.770
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -78.3 -78.1 -81.7 3.69 13.3 1.12 0.750 0.594 0.849 0.819 0.729
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -68.9 -68.6 -81.7 13.2 14.9 0.480 0.553 0.762 0.967 0.773 0.765
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -79.3 -79.3 -82.6 3.29 9.94 0.757 0.754 0.716 0.933 0.927 0.818
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -79.3
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -79.0 -79.4 -79.3 -0.0690 6.54 0.879 0.838 0.759 0.923 0.870 0.838
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -80.5 -80.8 -79.3 -1.46 9.11 0.457 0.787 0.684 0.959 0.805 0.795
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -81.2 -81.2 -78.6 -2.52 10.4 0.406 0.842 0.591 0.973 0.997 0.822
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -82.0 -82.4 -79.3 -3.06 6.69 0.789 0.802 0.773 0.943 0.878 0.840
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -82.6 -82.8 -79.3 -3.50 10.3 0.364 0.744 0.654 0.973 0.831 0.784
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -86.1 -86.1 -78.2 -7.96 13.3 0.450 0.658 0.588 0.970 0.774 0.730
CESM2_BARPA [-] -78.1 -78.5 -79.3 0.838 5.47 0.671 0.852 0.801 0.956 0.918 0.873
CESM2_CCAM [-] -84.6 -85.0 -79.3 -5.71 8.13 0.344 0.741 0.746 0.964 0.932 0.834
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -79.7 -80.1 -79.3 -0.787 6.20 0.764 0.853 0.768 0.940 0.905 0.855
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -78.1 -78.2 -79.3 1.05 9.42 0.602 0.738 0.717 0.960 0.809 0.796
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -75.3 -75.3 -78.2 2.83 8.35 0.210 0.768 0.709 0.986 0.998 0.848
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -86.0 -86.3 -79.3 -6.99 11.1 0.643 0.682 0.679 0.939 0.774 0.758
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -86.7 -86.7 -78.4 -8.37 11.5 0.586 0.635 0.663 0.961 0.959 0.789
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -85.6 -85.8 -79.3 -6.54 8.49 0.388 0.709 0.777 0.961 0.845 0.818
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -85.7 -86.0 -79.3 -6.66 11.6 0.295 0.694 0.660 0.980 0.805 0.771
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -91.2 -91.7 -79.3 -12.4 14.6 0.387 0.536 0.673 0.964 0.798 0.735
ERA5_BARPA [-] -78.4 -78.7 -79.3 0.558 5.85 0.505 0.828 0.800 0.951 0.847 0.850
ERA5_CCAM [-] -82.9 -83.1 -79.3 -3.78 9.07 0.319 0.718 0.740 0.968 0.802 0.799
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -82.8 -83.3 -79.3 -3.99 7.08 0.551 0.805 0.749 0.950 0.926 0.846
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -87.0 -87.3 -79.3 -8.06 11.3 0.318 0.660 0.662 0.968 0.884 0.779
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -75.7 -76.0 -79.3 3.30 8.42 0.811 0.782 0.721 0.933 0.832 0.806
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -76.1 -76.3 -79.3 2.96 8.79 0.833 0.740 0.750 0.929 0.746 0.787
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -74.6 -74.6 -78.2 3.52 8.02 0.588 0.802 0.710 0.958 0.970 0.843
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -105.
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -100. -99.9 -105. 5.35 9.68 1.05 0.749 0.701 0.878 0.953 0.817
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -96.6 -96.4 -105. 8.88 11.7 0.575 0.635 0.732 0.946 0.706 0.762
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -113. -113. -105. -7.13 13.2 0.628 0.709 0.590 0.920 0.990 0.785
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -104. -104. -105. 1.66 8.37 1.03 0.838 0.700 0.894 0.984 0.847
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -96.7 -96.5 -105. 8.80 12.1 0.937 0.643 0.698 0.903 0.947 0.797
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -113. -113. -105. -8.30 15.8 0.641 0.670 0.549 0.933 0.961 0.758
CESM2_BARPA [-] -104. -104. -105. 1.35 8.71 0.649 0.843 0.692 0.918 0.999 0.852
CESM2_CCAM [-] -108. -108. -105. -2.50 10.9 0.813 0.796 0.627 0.884 0.985 0.808
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -105. -105. -105. 0.440 11.3 0.945 0.865 0.594 0.886 0.998 0.818
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -87.3 -87.2 -105. 18.1 20.4 1.34 0.422 0.644 0.783 0.620 0.626
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -92.3 -92.3 -105. 12.8 17.5 1.72 0.543 0.572 0.713 0.775 0.653
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -99.1 -99.0 -105. 6.34 9.59 0.713 0.710 0.745 0.912 0.718 0.768
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -108. -108. -105. -2.48 9.94 0.458 0.831 0.649 0.937 0.683 0.762
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -109. -109. -105. -3.68 8.51 0.619 0.809 0.707 0.919 0.990 0.846
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -99.9 -99.7 -105. 5.61 10.9 1.34 0.733 0.658 0.790 0.828 0.753
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -107. -107. -105. -1.83 12.0 1.07 0.798 0.600 0.831 0.884 0.769
ERA5_BARPA [-] -102. -101. -105. 4.04 8.65 0.925 0.790 0.716 0.899 0.981 0.836
ERA5_CCAM [-] -96.9 -96.7 -105. 8.62 11.2 0.739 0.648 0.740 0.887 0.882 0.793
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -110. -109. -105. -3.99 8.76 0.520 0.802 0.701 0.935 0.996 0.847
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -109. -109. -105. -3.55 9.23 1.00 0.804 0.687 0.849 0.955 0.798
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -96.4 -96.2 -105. 9.13 15.0 1.12 0.632 0.578 0.851 0.929 0.739
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -84.6 -84.5 -105. 20.8 22.2 0.940 0.371 0.696 0.900 0.761 0.690
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -96.4 -96.4 -105. 8.70 12.0 0.868 0.642 0.702 0.887 0.988 0.801
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -56.2
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -59.4 -60.2 -56.2 -4.00 7.01 1.07 0.568 0.658 0.881 0.919 0.719
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -64.8 -64.9 -56.2 -8.74 11.5 0.867 0.399 0.530 0.914 0.832 0.681
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -63.9 -63.9 -58.8 -5.17 8.48 0.789 0.592 0.527 0.922 0.854 0.654
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -61.8 -62.6 -56.2 -6.46 8.94 1.12 0.470 0.637 0.884 0.867 0.705
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -61.4 -61.8 -56.2 -5.68 10.6 0.668 0.415 0.550 0.944 0.694 0.671
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -76.3 -76.3 -59.6 -16.8 18.3 1.51 0.153 0.457 0.765 0.840 0.482
CESM2_BARPA [-] -56.1 -57.1 -56.2 -0.916 5.73 0.611 0.687 0.657 0.944 0.946 0.744
CESM2_CCAM [-] -60.3 -60.7 -56.2 -4.49 8.92 0.861 0.442 0.660 0.907 0.652 0.698
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -57.6 -59.0 -56.2 -2.84 6.03 1.11 0.642 0.671 0.865 0.959 0.717
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -61.2 -62.0 -56.2 -5.87 7.64 0.861 0.529 0.670 0.907 0.978 0.720
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -61.6 -61.6 -58.9 -2.73 7.11 1.66 0.611 0.562 0.742 0.847 0.660
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -65.3 -65.7 -56.2 -9.55 12.8 1.02 0.349 0.501 0.885 0.723 0.626
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -66.1 -66.1 -57.3 -8.74 10.3 1.14 0.350 0.583 0.842 0.452 0.565
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -64.6 -65.7 -56.2 -9.53 10.7 0.506 0.389 0.636 0.966 0.951 0.668
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -64.1 -64.7 -56.2 -8.52 10.5 0.791 0.409 0.615 0.905 0.844 0.670
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -72.7 -73.1 -56.2 -17.0 17.8 1.67 0.175 0.553 0.744 0.951 0.566
ERA5_BARPA [-] -58.0 -59.2 -56.2 -3.01 5.72 0.605 0.665 0.677 0.948 0.991 0.731
ERA5_CCAM [-] -62.8 -63.3 -56.2 -7.18 8.84 0.552 0.478 0.666 0.949 0.934 0.695
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -60.8 -61.5 -56.2 -5.37 8.98 0.961 0.491 0.616 0.868 0.778 0.647
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -63.9 -65.8 -56.2 -9.64 14.2 1.11 0.311 0.460 0.854 0.671 0.575
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -56.7 -57.9 -56.2 -1.72 5.05 0.874 0.720 0.707 0.911 0.994 0.749
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -59.1 -59.4 -56.2 -3.20 7.13 0.919 0.574 0.633 0.894 0.888 0.725
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -56.4 -56.4 -58.9 2.45 6.45 1.02 0.625 0.635 0.879 0.643 0.707
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -81.5
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -80.7 -80.1 -81.5 1.44 6.93 1.17 0.763 0.749 0.892 0.907 0.808
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -86.6 -85.8 -81.5 -4.24 8.73 0.912 0.699 0.687 0.925 0.815 0.768
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -89.6 -89.6 -81.5 -8.04 11.9 1.02 0.588 0.597 0.919 0.994 0.766
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -84.6 -83.7 -81.5 -2.19 6.09 0.674 0.768 0.779 0.942 0.954 0.837
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -86.3 -85.4 -81.5 -3.92 8.07 0.778 0.742 0.697 0.926 0.958 0.812
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -97.8 -97.8 -83.0 -14.8 16.6 0.129 0.406 0.637 0.991 0.997 0.756
CESM2_BARPA [-] -81.0 -80.2 -81.5 1.37 6.52 1.02 0.793 0.758 0.906 0.987 0.845
CESM2_CCAM [-] -84.1 -83.3 -81.5 -1.79 8.05 1.12 0.745 0.691 0.902 0.992 0.816
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -81.9 -81.1 -81.5 0.445 6.40 0.883 0.789 0.761 0.916 0.982 0.841
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -80.0 -79.5 -81.5 2.01 9.57 0.722 0.705 0.679 0.921 0.788 0.760
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -83.6 -83.6 -81.7 -1.96 8.27 0.617 0.784 0.669 0.917 0.990 0.825
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -84.2 -83.9 -81.5 -2.41 8.34 0.645 0.687 0.724 0.933 0.813 0.774
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -90.4 -90.4 -83.4 -7.03 11.7 0.565 0.641 0.607 0.944 0.970 0.780
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -85.9 -85.1 -81.5 -3.62 7.57 1.04 0.713 0.744 0.890 0.916 0.803
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -85.8 -85.2 -81.5 -3.66 8.45 0.729 0.713 0.699 0.931 0.857 0.784
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -93.5 -92.8 -81.5 -11.2 14.0 0.933 0.519 0.616 0.889 0.827 0.700
ERA5_BARPA [-] -80.3 -79.8 -81.5 1.68 6.54 1.12 0.762 0.785 0.905 0.918 0.821
ERA5_CCAM [-] -86.2 -85.6 -81.5 -4.12 7.60 0.830 0.713 0.753 0.924 0.872 0.797
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -83.3 -82.4 -81.5 -0.909 6.62 0.911 0.793 0.730 0.922 0.985 0.840
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -90.8 -88.2 -81.5 -6.73 9.52 0.828 0.662 0.699 0.918 0.941 0.783
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -78.2 -77.8 -81.5 3.75 7.57 1.01 0.717 0.787 0.909 0.887 0.800
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -81.0 -80.2 -81.5 1.31 8.18 0.963 0.758 0.702 0.921 0.872 0.794
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -82.5 -82.5 -81.7 -0.822 7.05 0.892 0.790 0.731 0.925 0.999 0.836
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -51.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -61.1 -62.2 -51.4 -10.8 11.8 0.898 0.452 0.712 0.911 0.950 0.751
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -63.7 -63.8 -51.4 -12.4 14.1 0.998 0.404 0.611 0.905 0.993 0.715
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -70.1 -70.1 -55.5 -14.5 16.1 0.992 0.310 0.623 0.913 0.995 0.701
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -60.5 -61.5 -51.4 -10.1 11.2 0.704 0.472 0.715 0.905 0.953 0.756
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -58.2 -58.4 -51.4 -7.01 9.68 1.30 0.604 0.620 0.855 0.986 0.750
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -65.3 -65.3 -49.2 -16.2 18.4 1.51 0.203 0.428 0.781 0.998 0.583
CESM2_BARPA [-] -65.0 -65.9 -51.4 -14.5 15.7 0.800 0.333 0.656 0.899 0.930 0.699
CESM2_CCAM [-] -63.3 -63.7 -51.4 -12.3 13.4 1.21 0.394 0.682 0.812 0.951 0.707
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -65.5 -66.3 -51.4 -14.9 16.0 0.704 0.326 0.663 0.905 0.977 0.712
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -59.4 -60.0 -51.4 -8.58 9.48 0.704 0.532 0.769 0.905 0.942 0.785
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -66.3 -66.3 -53.4 -12.9 14.3 1.02 0.395 0.644 0.825 0.995 0.707
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -66.5 -66.8 -51.4 -15.4 16.6 0.901 0.323 0.645 0.881 0.998 0.704
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -77.7 -77.7 -51.4 -26.3 27.9 0.326 0.104 0.459 0.979 0.622 0.532
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -64.6 -65.5 -51.4 -14.1 16.0 0.702 0.341 0.568 0.906 0.911 0.669
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -59.3 -59.9 -51.4 -8.46 10.5 1.00 0.524 0.625 0.874 0.972 0.735
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -68.4 -67.5 -51.4 -16.1 20.9 0.800 0.289 0.376 0.899 0.990 0.609
ERA5_BARPA [-] -61.0 -62.0 -51.4 -10.6 11.9 0.704 0.448 0.671 0.905 0.951 0.736
ERA5_CCAM [-] -56.7 -57.4 -51.4 -5.94 6.93 0.704 0.644 0.812 0.905 0.955 0.827
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -66.5 -67.6 -51.4 -16.2 17.3 0.607 0.297 0.651 0.912 0.990 0.706
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -74.4 -76.0 -51.4 -24.6 25.7 0.704 0.156 0.574 0.905 0.915 0.631
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -59.2 -60.5 -51.4 -9.05 11.2 0.704 0.501 0.621 0.905 0.893 0.718
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -49.9 -50.4 -51.4 0.969 4.87 0.902 0.773 0.769 0.882 0.909 0.826
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -56.8 -56.8 -53.4 -3.41 6.52 1.02 0.684 0.712 0.825 0.932 0.780
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -57.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -58.6 -58.9 -58.1 -45.6 -0.753 5.66 1.95 0.592 0.572 0.701 0.979 0.683
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -56.1 -56.4 -58.3 -47.4 1.88 7.09 1.89 0.523 0.535 0.721 0.971 0.657
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -60.5 -60.7 -58.1 -54.8 -2.65 6.97 2.05 0.524 0.534 0.683 0.964 0.648
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -59.3 -59.7 -58.1 -45.6 -1.53 5.75 1.97 0.610 0.541 0.696 0.984 0.674
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -54.0 -54.3 -58.3 -47.4 4.07 7.65 1.83 0.480 0.558 0.727 0.971 0.659
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -60.5 -61.0 -58.3 -51.0 -2.72 6.36 1.87 0.633 0.535 0.714 0.976 0.678
CESM2_BARPA [-] -58.2 -58.6 -58.1 -45.6 -0.443 6.55 1.62 0.514 0.578 0.756 0.970 0.679
CESM2_CCAM [-] -59.0 -59.4 -58.3 -47.4 -1.06 11.2 1.66 0.347 0.492 0.760 0.906 0.600
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -58.0 -58.4 -58.1 -45.6 -0.302 6.43 1.68 0.544 0.576 0.749 0.974 0.684
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -57.9 -58.2 -58.3 -47.4 0.128 8.83 1.58 0.410 0.543 0.769 0.876 0.628
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -54.7 -55.0 -58.1 -49.0 3.08 6.81 1.70 0.537 0.556 0.745 0.976 0.674
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -56.9 -57.2 -58.3 -47.4 1.11 7.85 2.34 0.500 0.472 0.624 0.961 0.606
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -61.5 -62.2 -58.3 -51.6 -3.94 7.05 1.80 0.507 0.524 0.730 0.980 0.653
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -61.5 -61.8 -58.1 -45.6 -3.66 7.03 1.90 0.528 0.511 0.713 0.980 0.648
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -59.1 -59.4 -58.3 -47.4 -1.06 8.05 1.84 0.448 0.509 0.727 0.958 0.631
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -64.4 -64.6 -58.0 -45.3 -6.52 8.81 1.50 0.350 0.543 0.786 0.981 0.640
ERA5_BARPA [-] -58.5 -58.8 -58.1 -45.6 -0.687 5.41 1.57 0.601 0.641 0.760 0.977 0.724
ERA5_CCAM [-] -56.6 -56.9 -58.3 -47.4 1.42 7.42 1.40 0.433 0.638 0.789 0.954 0.690
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -59.3 -59.7 -58.1 -45.6 -1.53 6.66 2.08 0.512 0.555 0.671 0.963 0.651
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -61.8 -62.0 -57.9 -4.13 7.73 1.67 0.473 0.504 0.752 0.967 0.640
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -57.7 -58.0 -58.1 -45.6 0.126 6.41 1.77 0.560 0.556 0.735 0.968 0.675
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -49.9 -50.2 -58.3 -47.4 8.17 9.94 1.57 0.328 0.594 0.783 0.941 0.648
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -55.5 -55.7 -58.1 -50.3 2.39 6.11 1.69 0.560 0.574 0.755 0.981 0.689
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -48.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -48.9 -49.0 -48.2 -45.7 -0.772 5.32 1.89 0.538 0.520 0.710 0.915 0.640
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -49.4 -49.5 -48.2 -45.7 -1.34 7.17 2.12 0.501 0.404 0.669 0.891 0.574
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -51.6 -51.6 -48.1 -3.46 6.69 2.00 0.484 0.474 0.692 0.995 0.624
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -50.0 -50.0 -48.2 -45.7 -1.80 5.45 2.03 0.586 0.467 0.680 0.910 0.622
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -48.5 -48.6 -48.2 -45.7 -0.399 6.00 1.81 0.551 0.443 0.725 0.877 0.608
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -51.4 -51.5 -47.8 -50.1 -3.65 6.38 2.08 0.523 0.484 0.670 0.949 0.622
CESM2_BARPA [-] -49.3 -49.4 -48.2 -45.7 -1.24 6.50 2.42 0.447 0.473 0.604 0.994 0.598
CESM2_CCAM [-] -57.7 -58.0 -48.2 -45.7 -9.81 14.7 2.36 0.210 0.315 0.635 0.966 0.488
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -48.7 -49.0 -48.2 -45.7 -0.781 6.25 2.03 0.433 0.524 0.681 0.989 0.630
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -54.3 -54.3 -48.2 -45.7 -6.14 9.81 1.96 0.263 0.447 0.705 0.920 0.556
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -45.3 -45.4 -48.2 -43.2 2.75 5.01 1.89 0.505 0.567 0.714 0.990 0.668
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -52.8 -52.9 -48.2 -45.7 -4.69 7.86 1.71 0.433 0.357 0.750 0.976 0.574
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -53.3 -53.4 -48.4 -50.9 -5.06 7.25 1.66 0.407 0.449 0.753 0.925 0.596
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -50.5 -50.7 -48.2 -45.7 -2.47 7.00 2.26 0.471 0.420 0.640 0.990 0.588
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -54.0 -54.1 -48.2 -45.7 -5.92 9.03 1.60 0.314 0.376 0.778 0.864 0.541
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -53.1 -53.3 -48.1 -5.17 7.42 1.72 0.336 0.475 0.742 0.996 0.605
ERA5_BARPA [-] -49.7 -49.9 -48.2 -45.7 -1.68 4.75 1.66 0.580 0.593 0.751 0.951 0.693
ERA5_CCAM [-] -52.8 -52.8 -48.2 -45.7 -4.63 7.71 1.28 0.328 0.540 0.817 0.884 0.622
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -50.7 -50.9 -48.2 -45.7 -2.69 7.15 2.80 0.454 0.411 0.551 0.995 0.564
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -53.7 -53.8 -48.1 -5.72 8.19 2.03 0.353 0.414 0.682 0.986 0.570
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -48.2 -48.3 -48.2 -45.7 -0.0701 6.10 2.35 0.480 0.456 0.624 0.904 0.584
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -44.5 -44.5 -48.2 -45.7 3.72 6.90 1.78 0.401 0.515 0.738 0.827 0.599
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -48.2 -48.1 -48.2 -49.3 0.0226 4.48 1.99 0.581 0.514 0.699 0.988 0.659
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -82.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -82.9 -82.6 -82.4 -0.208 6.78 1.19 0.870 0.653 0.871 0.962 0.802
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -80.9 -80.8 -82.4 1.62 6.74 0.665 0.820 0.681 0.918 0.798 0.780
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -85.3 -85.3 -82.5 -2.75 9.33 0.431 0.830 0.560 0.946 0.988 0.777
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -83.9 -83.6 -82.4 -1.27 5.52 1.37 0.843 0.725 0.855 0.955 0.820
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -78.2 -78.1 -82.4 4.28 7.81 0.247 0.747 0.689 0.963 0.784 0.774
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -86.0 -86.0 -82.1 -3.86 9.12 0.621 0.771 0.579 0.950 0.941 0.764
CESM2_BARPA [-] -83.7 -83.3 -82.4 -0.905 5.77 0.488 0.864 0.709 0.937 0.981 0.840
CESM2_CCAM [-] -89.4 -89.2 -82.4 -6.86 8.58 0.451 0.635 0.721 0.960 0.902 0.788
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -85.5 -85.1 -82.4 -2.72 7.90 1.26 0.809 0.620 0.872 0.988 0.782
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -74.8 -74.7 -82.4 7.68 10.2 1.76 0.615 0.651 0.783 0.804 0.701
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -75.1 -75.1 -82.1 7.06 10.8 3.34 0.615 0.582 0.419 0.953 0.630
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -85.4 -85.3 -82.4 -2.88 8.49 0.492 0.783 0.602 0.943 0.820 0.750
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -89.1 -89.1 -82.5 -6.62 12.4 0.685 0.649 0.499 0.955 0.938 0.708
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -90.6 -90.2 -82.4 -7.85 9.56 0.317 0.589 0.701 0.948 0.970 0.782
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -87.6 -87.4 -82.4 -5.02 8.10 0.712 0.717 0.682 0.875 0.812 0.754
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -96.3 -96.0 -82.4 -13.7 15.5 0.647 0.403 0.613 0.893 0.990 0.702
ERA5_BARPA [-] -84.1 -83.7 -82.4 -1.33 6.70 0.318 0.856 0.662 0.948 0.976 0.821
ERA5_CCAM [-] -80.1 -79.9 -82.4 2.44 5.58 0.318 0.804 0.764 0.948 0.784 0.813
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -93.5 -93.1 -82.4 -10.7 12.5 0.352 0.490 0.655 0.945 0.983 0.745
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -95.5 -95.5 -82.4 -13.2 14.5 0.958 0.416 0.661 0.831 0.982 0.710
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -78.6 -78.3 -82.4 4.06 12.2 1.05 0.771 0.466 0.887 0.959 0.710
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -69.7 -69.6 -82.4 12.8 15.2 1.05 0.441 0.589 0.899 0.652 0.634
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -77.8 -77.8 -82.1 4.31 7.47 0.701 0.753 0.701 0.902 0.911 0.794
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -73.2
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -74.8 -75.1 -73.2 -1.96 6.53 1.34 0.832 0.726 0.835 0.786 0.781
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -76.5 -76.8 -73.2 -3.62 7.49 2.33 0.787 0.686 0.649 0.914 0.745
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -84.8 -84.8 -73.0 -11.8 14.4 2.02 0.447 0.609 0.699 0.987 0.670
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -73.9 -74.3 -73.2 -1.14 5.75 0.541 0.870 0.737 0.965 0.878 0.837
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -70.8 -71.2 -73.2 1.99 5.62 1.10 0.806 0.772 0.893 0.883 0.825
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -83.7 -83.7 -74.7 -9.02 12.3 1.91 0.555 0.597 0.744 1.00 0.698
CESM2_BARPA [-] -76.8 -77.3 -73.2 -4.12 8.83 0.297 0.759 0.636 0.981 0.832 0.769
CESM2_CCAM [-] -78.8 -79.3 -73.2 -6.07 7.99 0.445 0.687 0.740 0.971 0.998 0.827
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -78.4 -78.9 -73.2 -5.71 9.73 1.95 0.697 0.629 0.685 0.926 0.713
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -72.3 -72.7 -73.2 0.469 6.33 0.589 0.850 0.711 0.962 0.929 0.833
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -74.9 -74.9 -74.2 -0.760 6.22 0.924 0.796 0.740 0.889 0.955 0.824
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -77.7 -78.2 -73.2 -4.99 7.81 1.51 0.735 0.704 0.841 0.948 0.786
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -81.9 -81.9 -74.7 -7.12 10.8 2.02 0.627 0.600 0.740 1.00 0.713
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -81.2 -81.7 -73.2 -8.53 9.67 0.297 0.587 0.771 0.981 0.927 0.807
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -79.6 -80.0 -73.2 -6.78 8.36 0.395 0.655 0.764 0.975 0.969 0.825
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -89.4 -88.8 -73.2 -15.6 17.7 0.539 0.381 0.616 0.965 0.942 0.704
ERA5_BARPA [-] -76.4 -76.8 -73.2 -3.60 7.58 1.71 0.785 0.690 0.731 0.834 0.746
ERA5_CCAM [-] -72.9 -73.2 -73.2 -0.0652 4.75 0.686 0.854 0.803 0.956 0.889 0.861
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -84.4 -84.9 -73.2 -11.7 12.9 0.789 0.480 0.729 0.934 0.925 0.760
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -90.1 -90.3 -73.2 -17.1 17.9 0.686 0.343 0.736 0.956 0.886 0.732
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -72.5 -73.0 -73.2 0.208 10.5 2.72 0.849 0.544 0.566 0.787 0.658
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -62.3 -62.7 -73.2 10.5 12.7 1.05 0.540 0.659 0.872 0.750 0.696
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -72.8 -72.8 -74.2 1.36 6.27 0.884 0.867 0.690 0.879 0.994 0.824
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -62.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -68.0 -68.3 -62.1 -6.18 7.67 1.20 0.631 0.743 0.825 0.698 0.728
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -68.0 -68.4 -62.1 -6.34 8.68 1.20 0.625 0.644 0.888 0.918 0.744
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -74.8 -74.8 -65.7 -9.08 12.3 2.00 0.506 0.573 0.676 0.964 0.658
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -67.5 -67.6 -62.1 -5.47 7.03 0.293 0.666 0.731 0.981 0.919 0.805
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -63.0 -63.4 -62.1 -1.33 5.63 0.691 0.841 0.679 0.955 0.983 0.827
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -76.2 -76.2 -66.7 -9.56 12.3 1.24 0.440 0.522 0.865 1.00 0.670
CESM2_BARPA [-] -66.0 -66.7 -62.1 -4.58 6.74 0.489 0.696 0.717 0.969 0.514 0.722
CESM2_CCAM [-] -69.9 -70.3 -62.1 -8.22 9.57 0.588 0.535 0.694 0.962 0.998 0.777
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -66.3 -66.8 -62.1 -4.73 6.62 0.294 0.695 0.729 0.981 0.753 0.778
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -60.9 -61.7 -62.1 0.379 4.51 0.292 0.851 0.734 0.981 0.636 0.787
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -57.2 -57.2 -64.9 7.72 10.1 2.32 0.561 0.624 0.652 0.768 0.646
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -70.3 -70.7 -62.1 -8.58 12.7 1.91 0.519 0.488 0.765 0.993 0.651
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -73.1 -73.1 -64.1 -9.05 13.1 2.01 0.486 0.484 0.740 0.657 0.570
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -71.6 -71.8 -62.1 -9.73 11.1 0.490 0.474 0.680 0.969 0.766 0.714
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -70.0 -70.4 -62.1 -8.30 9.92 0.293 0.524 0.663 0.981 0.971 0.761
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -79.6 -80.0 -62.1 -17.9 19.6 0.694 0.254 0.565 0.925 0.949 0.652
ERA5_BARPA [-] -66.5 -67.0 -62.1 -4.89 6.54 0.802 0.684 0.762 0.888 0.566 0.732
ERA5_CCAM [-] -65.1 -65.7 -62.1 -3.64 5.16 1.10 0.761 0.787 0.868 0.803 0.801
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -76.7 -76.9 -62.1 -14.8 15.7 0.904 0.316 0.686 0.881 0.807 0.675
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -81.1 -81.6 -62.1 -19.5 20.8 1.30 0.218 0.592 0.808 0.998 0.642
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -63.6 -64.3 -62.1 -2.19 6.97 1.89 0.774 0.651 0.747 0.788 0.722
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -59.4 -59.7 -62.1 2.35 6.85 1.10 0.726 0.655 0.869 0.986 0.778
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -59.4 -59.4 -64.9 5.51 6.79 0.437 0.641 0.729 0.972 0.996 0.813
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -85.2
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -83.9 -84.0 -85.2 1.25 9.08 0.821 0.768 0.714 0.913 0.793 0.780
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -86.2 -85.8 -85.2 -0.630 9.51 1.03 0.763 0.706 0.888 0.797 0.772
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -92.3 -92.3 -83.4 -8.90 15.1 1.61 0.636 0.559 0.801 0.885 0.688
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -84.4 -84.5 -85.2 0.740 7.90 0.389 0.794 0.746 0.975 0.848 0.822
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -78.9 -78.6 -85.2 6.62 10.8 1.13 0.688 0.711 0.902 0.813 0.765
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -89.8 -89.8 -83.8 -5.98 14.5 1.29 0.715 0.543 0.813 0.914 0.706
CESM2_BARPA [-] -89.5 -89.5 -85.2 -4.34 11.1 0.737 0.774 0.644 0.918 0.846 0.765
CESM2_CCAM [-] -89.8 -89.6 -85.2 -4.40 10.4 0.327 0.783 0.664 0.979 0.951 0.808
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -90.8 -90.8 -85.2 -5.59 11.9 1.22 0.752 0.635 0.811 0.875 0.742
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -81.4 -81.1 -85.2 4.06 8.60 0.327 0.744 0.763 0.979 0.803 0.811
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -81.4 -81.4 -85.5 4.04 11.3 0.328 0.720 0.670 0.979 0.696 0.747
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -88.0 -87.8 -85.2 -2.62 7.82 0.701 0.756 0.805 0.912 0.877 0.831
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -96.1 -96.1 -83.0 -13.1 17.6 1.22 0.543 0.581 0.861 0.994 0.712
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -89.8 -89.9 -85.2 -4.66 8.27 0.488 0.769 0.763 0.964 0.881 0.828
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -83.8 -83.7 -85.2 1.55 7.97 0.449 0.806 0.732 0.969 0.909 0.830
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -89.4 -89.1 -85.2 -3.93 15.0 0.427 0.740 0.516 0.970 0.805 0.710
ERA5_BARPA [-] -85.2 -85.3 -85.2 -0.0724 8.67 0.822 0.799 0.707 0.885 0.846 0.789
ERA5_CCAM [-] -78.9 -78.8 -85.2 6.43 8.25 0.327 0.709 0.841 0.979 0.894 0.853
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -93.3 -93.3 -85.2 -8.08 11.4 0.575 0.674 0.719 0.931 0.896 0.788
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -96.9 -97.0 -85.2 -11.8 13.5 0.327 0.559 0.763 0.979 0.895 0.792
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -82.3 -82.5 -85.2 2.74 12.5 1.93 0.774 0.583 0.681 0.794 0.683
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -69.4 -69.3 -85.2 15.9 16.7 0.371 0.461 0.797 0.970 0.823 0.770
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -77.0 -77.0 -85.5 8.47 10.8 0.838 0.654 0.749 0.902 0.860 0.783
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -79.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -77.7 -77.0 -79.4 2.33 11.1 0.598 0.746 0.686 0.960 0.770 0.770
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -77.6 -77.0 -79.4 2.40 12.2 0.770 0.762 0.629 0.928 0.727 0.735
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -89.2 -89.2 -80.1 -9.12 15.1 0.782 0.652 0.595 0.927 0.908 0.736
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -80.0 -79.2 -79.4 0.199 10.7 0.569 0.768 0.680 0.963 0.843 0.787
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -76.2 -75.5 -79.4 3.92 12.8 0.845 0.746 0.611 0.910 0.855 0.747
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -91.3 -91.3 -81.0 -10.3 18.8 0.687 0.617 0.500 0.956 0.986 0.712
CESM2_BARPA [-] -84.5 -83.6 -79.4 -4.20 11.9 0.569 0.755 0.651 0.963 0.869 0.778
CESM2_CCAM [-] -90.9 -89.8 -79.4 -10.4 16.1 0.569 0.624 0.589 0.963 0.998 0.753
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -84.5 -83.4 -79.4 -4.07 13.3 0.569 0.753 0.613 0.963 0.875 0.763
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -73.5 -73.0 -79.4 6.34 10.9 0.569 0.697 0.748 0.963 0.553 0.742
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -77.6 -77.6 -80.7 3.08 12.4 0.613 0.732 0.644 0.961 0.649 0.726
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -82.1 -81.6 -79.4 -2.25 8.36 0.569 0.771 0.779 0.963 0.809 0.820
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -98.4 -98.4 -81.4 -17.0 19.9 0.747 0.457 0.642 0.925 0.928 0.719
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -83.0 -82.1 -79.4 -2.78 9.41 1.14 0.778 0.723 0.894 0.905 0.804
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -76.2 -75.7 -79.4 3.67 9.80 0.598 0.751 0.722 0.962 0.852 0.802
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -82.5 -81.9 -79.4 -2.56 16.2 0.611 0.753 0.518 0.961 0.767 0.703
ERA5_BARPA [-] -79.8 -79.1 -79.4 0.263 9.95 0.583 0.768 0.707 0.961 0.810 0.791
ERA5_CCAM [-] -74.4 -74.0 -79.4 5.41 8.76 0.526 0.716 0.834 0.966 0.857 0.841
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -86.7 -85.9 -79.4 -6.51 11.5 0.569 0.713 0.701 0.963 0.896 0.795
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -95.2 -93.8 -79.4 -14.4 17.3 0.625 0.524 0.681 0.957 0.855 0.740
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -75.7 -75.0 -79.4 4.33 13.7 0.569 0.733 0.602 0.963 0.743 0.729
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -68.6 -68.1 -79.4 11.3 13.6 0.554 0.616 0.737 0.964 0.759 0.763
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -80.9 -80.9 -80.7 -0.249 9.36 0.702 0.823 0.693 0.955 0.956 0.824
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -79.3
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -79.0 -79.4 -79.3 -0.0690 6.54 0.879 0.838 0.759 0.923 0.870 0.830
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -80.5 -80.8 -79.3 -1.46 9.11 0.457 0.787 0.684 0.959 0.805 0.784
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -81.2 -81.2 -78.6 -2.52 10.4 0.406 0.842 0.591 0.973 0.997 0.799
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -82.0 -82.4 -79.3 -3.06 6.69 0.789 0.802 0.773 0.943 0.878 0.834
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -82.6 -82.8 -79.3 -3.50 10.3 0.364 0.744 0.654 0.973 0.831 0.771
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -86.1 -86.1 -78.2 -7.96 13.3 0.450 0.658 0.588 0.970 0.774 0.716
CESM2_BARPA [-] -78.1 -78.5 -79.3 0.838 5.47 0.671 0.852 0.801 0.956 0.918 0.866
CESM2_CCAM [-] -84.6 -85.0 -79.3 -5.71 8.13 0.344 0.741 0.746 0.964 0.932 0.825
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -79.7 -80.1 -79.3 -0.787 6.20 0.764 0.853 0.768 0.940 0.905 0.847
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -78.1 -78.2 -79.3 1.05 9.42 0.602 0.738 0.717 0.960 0.809 0.788
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -75.3 -75.3 -78.2 2.83 8.35 0.210 0.768 0.709 0.986 0.998 0.834
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -86.0 -86.3 -79.3 -6.99 11.1 0.643 0.682 0.679 0.939 0.774 0.750
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -86.7 -86.7 -78.4 -8.37 11.5 0.586 0.635 0.663 0.961 0.959 0.776
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -85.6 -85.8 -79.3 -6.54 8.49 0.388 0.709 0.777 0.961 0.845 0.814
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -85.7 -86.0 -79.3 -6.66 11.6 0.295 0.694 0.660 0.980 0.805 0.760
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -91.2 -91.7 -79.3 -12.4 14.6 0.387 0.536 0.673 0.964 0.798 0.729
ERA5_BARPA [-] -78.4 -78.7 -79.3 0.558 5.85 0.505 0.828 0.800 0.951 0.847 0.845
ERA5_CCAM [-] -82.9 -83.1 -79.3 -3.78 9.07 0.319 0.718 0.740 0.968 0.802 0.793
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -82.8 -83.3 -79.3 -3.99 7.08 0.551 0.805 0.749 0.950 0.926 0.836
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -87.0 -87.3 -79.3 -8.06 11.3 0.318 0.660 0.662 0.968 0.884 0.767
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -75.7 -76.0 -79.3 3.30 8.42 0.811 0.782 0.721 0.933 0.832 0.798
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -76.1 -76.3 -79.3 2.96 8.79 0.833 0.740 0.750 0.929 0.746 0.783
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -74.6 -74.6 -78.2 3.52 8.02 0.588 0.802 0.710 0.958 0.970 0.830
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -107.
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -101. -101. -107. 6.05 10.6 1.26 0.723 0.672 0.832 0.967 0.773
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -96.1 -96.1 -107. 10.8 13.2 0.437 0.578 0.707 0.947 0.809 0.750
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -113. -113. -107. -6.07 13.1 0.725 0.744 0.570 0.890 0.975 0.750
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -105. -104. -107. 2.46 9.08 1.26 0.824 0.673 0.858 0.995 0.805
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -95.9 -95.8 -107. 11.1 14.2 1.05 0.571 0.665 0.873 0.993 0.754
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -113. -113. -107. -6.38 16.3 0.874 0.729 0.493 0.906 0.908 0.706
CESM2_BARPA [-] -106. -106. -107. 0.901 9.44 0.799 0.846 0.657 0.884 0.988 0.806
CESM2_CCAM [-] -110. -110. -107. -3.07 11.3 1.03 0.794 0.608 0.839 0.999 0.769
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -107. -107. -107. -0.459 12.1 1.33 0.873 0.561 0.828 0.955 0.756
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -88.0 -87.9 -107. 18.9 21.1 1.87 0.396 0.630 0.697 0.632 0.597
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -91.1 -91.1 -107. 15.5 20.2 2.23 0.464 0.525 0.628 0.788 0.586
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -100. -100. -107. 6.56 9.82 1.03 0.698 0.727 0.871 0.713 0.747
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -109. -109. -107. -2.19 10.1 0.712 0.840 0.633 0.902 0.563 0.714
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -111. -111. -107. -3.62 8.34 0.916 0.823 0.704 0.875 0.998 0.821
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -100. -100. -107. 6.75 11.7 1.62 0.701 0.635 0.742 0.909 0.724
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -107. -107. -107. 0.252 12.8 1.37 0.836 0.548 0.785 0.974 0.738
ERA5_BARPA [-] -103. -103. -107. 3.77 8.67 0.979 0.794 0.704 0.873 0.954 0.806
ERA5_CCAM [-] -96.5 -96.4 -107. 10.5 12.5 1.11 0.588 0.729 0.829 0.971 0.770
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -112. -112. -107. -4.89 9.47 0.685 0.785 0.680 0.909 0.959 0.803
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -112. -112. -107. -4.99 9.76 1.09 0.778 0.678 0.837 0.787 0.752
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -97.6 -97.5 -107. 9.36 16.6 1.57 0.620 0.512 0.776 0.879 0.660
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -83.7 -83.7 -107. 23.2 24.6 1.05 0.316 0.668 0.870 0.901 0.685
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -97.7 -97.7 -107. 8.95 12.5 1.06 0.628 0.686 0.843 0.988 0.766
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -103.
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -99.1 -98.5 -103. 4.22 8.28 0.720 0.789 0.746 0.952 0.955 0.837
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -97.3 -96.9 -103. 5.82 9.32 0.794 0.725 0.771 0.944 0.668 0.776
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -112. -112. -103. -8.86 13.5 0.469 0.651 0.622 0.969 0.989 0.771
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -103. -102. -103. 0.383 7.25 0.676 0.861 0.743 0.952 0.984 0.857
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -98.0 -97.6 -103. 5.19 8.78 0.756 0.758 0.750 0.949 0.912 0.824
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -114. -114. -102. -11.2 14.9 0.280 0.581 0.635 0.975 0.967 0.758
CESM2_BARPA [-] -101. -101. -103. 2.06 7.56 0.411 0.837 0.747 0.972 0.999 0.861
CESM2_CCAM [-] -105. -104. -103. -1.60 10.2 0.472 0.800 0.657 0.956 0.928 0.800
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -102. -101. -103. 1.87 10.0 0.330 0.853 0.646 0.977 0.999 0.824
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -86.2 -85.9 -103. 16.8 19.2 0.498 0.463 0.667 0.921 0.613 0.666
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -94.2 -94.2 -103. 8.47 13.0 0.912 0.669 0.647 0.849 0.742 0.711
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -97.1 -96.8 -103. 5.99 9.22 0.213 0.728 0.772 0.978 0.663 0.783
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -106. -106. -103. -3.00 9.65 0.0136 0.816 0.675 0.999 0.722 0.778
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -107. -107. -103. -3.78 8.78 0.145 0.786 0.712 0.990 0.979 0.836
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -99.4 -99.0 -103. 3.80 9.66 0.885 0.785 0.694 0.866 0.793 0.766
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -108. -108. -103. -5.14 10.7 0.609 0.737 0.683 0.905 0.815 0.764
ERA5_BARPA [-] -98.9 -98.3 -103. 4.47 8.61 0.840 0.785 0.736 0.941 0.982 0.836
ERA5_CCAM [-] -97.4 -97.1 -103. 5.69 9.14 0.155 0.742 0.756 0.978 0.821 0.811
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -106. -105. -103. -2.56 7.63 0.257 0.830 0.736 0.978 0.993 0.855
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -105. -104. -103. -1.24 8.38 0.863 0.843 0.703 0.867 0.901 0.803
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -94.5 -94.0 -103. 8.75 12.5 0.417 0.650 0.682 0.970 0.945 0.786
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -86.0 -85.7 -103. 17.0 18.4 0.769 0.460 0.740 0.948 0.640 0.706
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -94.4 -94.4 -103. 8.28 11.3 0.553 0.665 0.727 0.959 0.990 0.814
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -48.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -59.2 -58.1 -48.9 -9.18 9.58 0.671 0.363 0.703 0.917 0.526 0.642
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -65.7 -63.4 -48.9 -14.5 15.3 0.00 0.184 0.541 1.00 0.864 0.626
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -56.2 -56.2 -53.3 -2.82 7.28 1.01 0.696 0.406 0.876 0.287 0.534
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -62.2 -60.9 -48.9 -12.0 12.5 0.676 0.249 0.652 0.955 0.735 0.649
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -64.0 -61.3 -48.9 -12.4 13.1 0.00 0.236 0.608 1.00 0.909 0.672
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -77.8 -77.8 -61.9 -15.9 16.3 6.03 0.0459 0.489 0.000167 1.00 0.405
CESM2_BARPA [-] -56.5 -55.5 -48.9 -6.63 7.32 0.335 0.506 0.698 0.978 0.425 0.661
CESM2_CCAM [-] -58.6 -55.9 -48.9 -7.00 7.26 0.676 0.453 0.771 0.955 0.945 0.779
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -57.8 -57.2 -48.9 -8.34 8.76 0.335 0.426 0.723 0.978 0.235 0.617
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -62.4 -60.7 -48.9 -11.9 12.1 0.335 0.263 0.738 0.978 0.558 0.655
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -62.5 -62.5 -55.4 -7.11 7.71 2.06 0.360 0.602 0.619 0.685 0.574
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -66.6 -64.4 -48.9 -15.5 16.4 0.671 0.166 0.518 0.917 0.700 0.564
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -68.3 -68.3 -57.6 -10.8 11.2 0.503 0.271 0.640 0.967 0.149 0.533
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -63.6 -62.9 -48.9 -14.0 14.3 1.02 0.209 0.674 0.932 0.207 0.539
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -63.7 -61.9 -48.9 -13.1 13.2 1.02 0.230 0.740 0.932 0.531 0.635
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -68.7 -67.4 -48.9 -18.5 19.5 4.02 0.131 0.478 0.336 0.772 0.439
ERA5_BARPA [-] -57.2 -56.8 -48.9 -7.88 8.90 0.335 0.476 0.663 0.978 0.0553 0.567
ERA5_CCAM [-] -63.7 -62.3 -48.9 -13.4 13.6 0.335 0.231 0.733 0.978 0.334 0.602
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -60.7 -59.6 -48.9 -10.7 11.5 0.335 0.307 0.598 0.978 0.437 0.584
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -62.6 -59.6 -48.9 -10.7 13.0 1.01 0.366 0.485 0.833 0.945 0.623
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -56.6 -56.0 -48.9 -7.14 7.76 0.676 0.507 0.731 0.955 0.123 0.610
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -59.8 -57.7 -48.9 -8.79 9.56 0.335 0.377 0.631 0.978 0.736 0.670
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -54.5 -54.5 -55.4 0.881 2.32 1.01 0.853 0.704 0.875 0.969 0.821
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -50.6
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -45.1 -46.7 -50.6 3.86 6.00 0.775 0.627 0.590 0.948 0.605 0.672
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -48.2 -49.3 -50.6 1.21 5.34 1.29 0.712 0.569 0.855 0.840 0.709
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -54.7 -54.7 -51.8 -2.97 5.45 1.03 0.587 0.437 0.930 1.00 0.678
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -46.3 -47.9 -50.6 2.70 6.27 1.54 0.687 0.506 0.838 0.768 0.661
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -41.9 -42.9 -50.6 7.68 9.06 0.521 0.368 0.593 0.965 0.918 0.687
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -67.0 -67.0 -52.6 -14.4 15.1 0.513 0.110 0.510 0.966 0.0881 0.437
CESM2_BARPA [-] -43.1 -44.4 -50.6 6.16 8.09 0.504 0.447 0.537 0.967 0.473 0.592
CESM2_CCAM [-] -40.3 -41.8 -50.6 8.71 9.62 1.29 0.310 0.613 0.809 0.864 0.642
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -45.1 -46.8 -50.6 3.78 5.94 2.03 0.608 0.600 0.716 0.563 0.617
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -48.9 -50.7 -50.6 -0.152 4.47 1.28 0.623 0.661 0.885 0.733 0.713
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -54.8 -54.8 -53.5 -1.28 4.07 0.683 0.727 0.576 0.954 0.874 0.742
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -46.2 -47.3 -50.6 3.26 5.87 1.03 0.631 0.575 0.902 0.832 0.703
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -58.5 -58.5 -54.0 -4.54 7.00 1.02 0.471 0.493 0.892 0.554 0.581
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -51.8 -53.2 -50.6 -2.63 5.77 0.254 0.667 0.542 0.983 0.302 0.607
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -48.3 -49.5 -50.6 1.07 4.32 2.02 0.705 0.649 0.643 0.638 0.657
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -62.0 -62.2 -50.6 -11.7 12.2 3.03 0.239 0.620 0.499 0.854 0.566
ERA5_BARPA [-] -46.6 -48.2 -50.6 2.36 5.18 1.28 0.639 0.601 0.886 0.392 0.624
ERA5_CCAM [-] -49.5 -50.2 -50.6 0.331 3.93 1.02 0.705 0.697 0.857 0.388 0.669
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -44.1 -45.6 -50.6 4.98 7.50 1.77 0.543 0.508 0.687 0.595 0.568
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -47.3 -49.9 -50.6 0.627 12.5 1.75 0.267 0.334 0.738 0.530 0.441
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -45.5 -47.1 -50.6 3.50 5.04 0.254 0.609 0.714 0.983 0.501 0.704
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -43.9 -44.9 -50.6 5.61 7.17 1.02 0.483 0.633 0.857 0.590 0.639
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -43.4 -43.4 -53.5 10.0 10.7 0.350 0.215 0.618 0.976 0.767 0.639
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -59.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -65.1 -65.1 -59.7 -5.43 7.14 1.58 0.512 0.613 0.794 0.870 0.680
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -71.3 -71.2 -59.7 -11.6 13.1 1.44 0.239 0.482 0.856 0.954 0.602
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -68.8 -68.8 -63.2 -5.59 10.9 1.02 0.596 0.413 0.893 0.345 0.532
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -67.7 -68.1 -59.7 -8.47 9.51 1.15 0.351 0.626 0.856 0.906 0.673
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -68.0 -68.5 -59.7 -8.79 10.6 1.15 0.343 0.488 0.891 0.817 0.606
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -81.3 -81.3 -62.2 -19.1 20.5 1.70 0.0946 0.397 0.726 0.285 0.380
CESM2_BARPA [-] -61.5 -62.0 -59.7 -2.33 4.74 0.867 0.763 0.634 0.900 0.864 0.759
CESM2_CCAM [-] -70.1 -69.5 -59.7 -9.84 10.7 1.01 0.303 0.607 0.890 0.727 0.627
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -62.6 -63.8 -59.7 -4.12 5.91 1.16 0.608 0.623 0.847 0.852 0.711
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -63.1 -63.8 -59.7 -4.16 5.58 1.15 0.597 0.648 0.839 0.738 0.694
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -62.9 -62.9 -61.4 -1.46 9.10 2.52 0.508 0.452 0.573 0.493 0.495
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -71.7 -71.7 -59.7 -12.0 14.0 1.30 0.226 0.411 0.829 0.841 0.544
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -69.6 -69.6 -59.8 -9.79 11.6 2.03 0.332 0.569 0.665 0.0584 0.439
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -68.8 -69.7 -59.7 -10.0 11.0 0.430 0.290 0.596 0.972 0.995 0.690
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -68.8 -69.1 -59.7 -9.48 10.9 0.288 0.311 0.525 0.981 0.995 0.667
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -76.8 -76.9 -59.7 -17.2 17.9 1.00 0.123 0.548 0.849 0.823 0.578
ERA5_BARPA [-] -62.3 -62.9 -59.7 -3.23 4.80 0.147 0.681 0.678 0.990 0.995 0.804
ERA5_CCAM [-] -66.0 -66.3 -59.7 -6.58 7.55 0.430 0.452 0.641 0.972 0.992 0.740
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -69.3 -69.2 -59.7 -9.53 11.1 0.875 0.331 0.586 0.873 0.441 0.563
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -73.4 -73.3 -59.7 -13.6 16.4 1.02 0.211 0.427 0.863 0.434 0.473
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -60.7 -61.5 -59.7 -1.87 4.71 1.16 0.770 0.633 0.855 0.952 0.769
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -64.1 -64.2 -59.7 -4.48 6.28 1.16 0.575 0.600 0.854 0.993 0.725
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -60.6 -60.6 -61.4 0.866 6.81 1.35 0.572 0.557 0.811 0.470 0.593
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -59.0
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -62.4 -63.7 -59.0 -4.76 6.27 0.851 0.694 0.733 0.924 0.987 0.814
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -67.4 -67.9 -59.0 -8.94 11.8 0.338 0.493 0.559 0.978 0.980 0.714
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -66.7 -66.7 -59.8 -6.90 7.69 0.339 0.526 0.748 0.978 0.598 0.720
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -65.0 -66.2 -59.0 -7.18 8.29 1.02 0.578 0.723 0.913 0.957 0.778
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -65.0 -66.1 -59.0 -7.15 10.4 0.506 0.614 0.569 0.966 0.650 0.674
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -76.9 -76.9 -61.0 -15.8 18.9 0.00 0.335 0.483 1.00 0.911 0.642
CESM2_BARPA [-] -58.5 -59.9 -59.0 -0.960 4.68 0.506 0.832 0.738 0.966 0.996 0.854
CESM2_CCAM [-] -62.6 -64.2 -59.0 -5.25 7.14 0.506 0.681 0.698 0.966 0.743 0.757
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -60.1 -61.9 -59.0 -2.87 4.94 0.851 0.804 0.748 0.924 1.00 0.845
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -66.6 -67.6 -59.0 -8.60 9.93 0.506 0.518 0.667 0.966 0.954 0.754
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -63.6 -63.6 -60.2 -3.44 6.18 1.02 0.768 0.673 0.873 0.808 0.759
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -69.6 -70.8 -59.0 -11.8 14.1 0.851 0.403 0.554 0.924 0.762 0.639
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -72.8 -72.8 -59.2 -13.7 13.8 0.00 0.212 0.775 1.00 1.00 0.752
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -68.9 -70.1 -59.0 -11.1 11.7 0.509 0.416 0.722 0.966 0.982 0.761
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -69.3 -70.2 -59.0 -11.2 12.5 0.506 0.423 0.642 0.966 0.773 0.689
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -77.0 -78.2 -59.0 -19.3 20.5 0.506 0.216 0.553 0.966 0.899 0.638
ERA5_BARPA [-] -61.2 -62.8 -59.0 -3.79 5.64 0.851 0.752 0.729 0.924 0.947 0.816
ERA5_CCAM [-] -67.4 -68.6 -59.0 -9.62 11.1 0.506 0.482 0.646 0.966 0.826 0.713
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -62.0 -63.4 -59.0 -4.40 6.19 0.852 0.734 0.728 0.924 0.954 0.813
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -68.5 -69.9 -59.0 -10.9 13.4 0.851 0.428 0.565 0.924 0.979 0.692
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -59.6 -61.2 -59.0 -2.24 4.16 1.02 0.831 0.777 0.913 0.826 0.825
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -62.8 -63.5 -59.0 -4.54 6.96 0.851 0.723 0.673 0.924 0.968 0.792
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -59.5 -59.5 -60.2 0.683 5.18 1.01 0.835 0.713 0.910 0.587 0.752
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -78.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -81.0 -79.2 -78.1 -1.03 5.98 1.22 0.767 0.728 0.872 0.733 0.766
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -86.6 -84.3 -78.1 -6.13 8.78 0.809 0.609 0.686 0.899 0.806 0.737
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -84.4 -84.4 -77.9 -6.51 7.65 0.762 0.615 0.745 0.950 0.928 0.797
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -83.4 -81.2 -78.1 -3.10 6.31 1.11 0.710 0.745 0.897 0.808 0.781
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -85.6 -83.2 -78.1 -5.03 8.68 0.703 0.666 0.659 0.895 0.945 0.765
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -93.1 -93.1 -83.8 -9.30 12.3 0.00 0.593 0.631 1.00 0.952 0.762
CESM2_BARPA [-] -79.3 -77.1 -78.1 1.07 4.93 1.01 0.856 0.762 0.875 0.857 0.823
CESM2_CCAM [-] -86.0 -83.5 -78.1 -5.35 7.61 1.11 0.677 0.696 0.879 0.976 0.785
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -80.5 -78.5 -78.1 -0.326 5.61 1.11 0.810 0.726 0.879 0.833 0.794
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -82.5 -80.6 -78.1 -2.51 9.30 0.802 0.655 0.664 0.888 0.758 0.726
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -80.7 -80.7 -81.3 0.568 8.99 0.143 0.807 0.626 0.990 0.929 0.796
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -88.3 -86.5 -78.1 -8.38 10.6 0.702 0.558 0.682 0.906 0.823 0.730
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -93.0 -93.0 -84.0 -9.04 11.3 0.00 0.581 0.684 1.00 0.966 0.783
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -87.8 -85.2 -78.1 -7.07 8.96 0.399 0.572 0.738 0.944 0.872 0.773
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -88.1 -85.7 -78.1 -7.58 11.0 0.599 0.585 0.635 0.902 0.902 0.732
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -92.2 -91.5 -78.1 -13.3 15.7 0.901 0.427 0.557 0.852 0.892 0.657
ERA5_BARPA [-] -80.0 -78.4 -78.1 -0.309 5.98 1.11 0.783 0.727 0.897 0.702 0.767
ERA5_CCAM [-] -86.6 -84.9 -78.1 -6.81 9.88 0.700 0.600 0.683 0.895 0.810 0.734
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -83.3 -80.8 -78.1 -2.71 5.94 0.600 0.744 0.730 0.913 0.911 0.805
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -91.2 -86.3 -78.1 -8.21 11.8 0.998 0.570 0.579 0.828 0.955 0.702
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -77.2 -76.2 -78.1 1.97 6.87 0.806 0.749 0.705 0.917 0.590 0.733
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -78.5 -76.8 -78.1 1.37 7.50 1.11 0.730 0.709 0.879 0.772 0.760
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -77.4 -77.4 -81.3 3.93 7.26 0.439 0.829 0.731 0.971 0.739 0.800
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -82.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -80.6 -80.4 -82.7 2.28 7.26 1.16 0.761 0.757 0.899 0.933 0.821
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -86.6 -86.3 -82.7 -3.60 8.71 0.947 0.730 0.687 0.933 0.823 0.772
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -91.1 -91.1 -82.6 -8.51 13.1 1.10 0.580 0.552 0.909 0.978 0.714
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -84.8 -84.6 -82.7 -1.89 6.02 0.525 0.788 0.791 0.957 0.969 0.859
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -86.5 -86.2 -82.7 -3.54 7.87 0.803 0.768 0.710 0.937 0.962 0.817
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -98.8 -98.8 -82.8 -16.0 17.6 0.158 0.363 0.639 0.990 0.997 0.725
CESM2_BARPA [-] -81.5 -81.2 -82.7 1.47 7.05 1.02 0.771 0.756 0.917 0.994 0.839
CESM2_CCAM [-] -83.6 -83.3 -82.7 -0.590 8.19 1.12 0.768 0.689 0.910 0.996 0.810
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -82.2 -82.0 -82.7 0.706 6.67 0.804 0.782 0.773 0.929 0.992 0.850
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -79.3 -79.1 -82.7 3.54 9.66 0.695 0.721 0.684 0.932 0.801 0.765
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -84.4 -84.4 -81.8 -2.64 8.07 0.742 0.778 0.680 0.898 0.991 0.805
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -83.1 -83.1 -82.7 -0.391 7.57 0.626 0.730 0.738 0.943 0.804 0.790
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -89.7 -89.7 -83.2 -6.53 11.8 0.704 0.656 0.588 0.930 0.966 0.746
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -85.4 -85.1 -82.7 -2.45 7.10 1.26 0.760 0.746 0.872 0.931 0.811
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -85.2 -85.0 -82.7 -2.33 7.60 0.773 0.757 0.720 0.941 0.858 0.799
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -93.9 -93.2 -82.7 -10.5 13.5 0.944 0.550 0.636 0.901 0.821 0.709
ERA5_BARPA [-] -80.4 -80.3 -82.7 2.36 6.73 1.12 0.755 0.804 0.908 0.944 0.843
ERA5_CCAM [-] -86.1 -85.9 -82.7 -3.21 6.83 0.874 0.751 0.777 0.934 0.891 0.826
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -83.3 -83.0 -82.7 -0.299 6.85 1.02 0.809 0.730 0.925 0.993 0.837
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -90.7 -88.9 -82.7 -6.22 8.75 0.770 0.693 0.740 0.949 0.943 0.813
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -78.4 -78.3 -82.7 4.36 7.80 1.09 0.706 0.815 0.906 0.920 0.832
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -81.6 -81.4 -82.7 1.29 8.41 0.912 0.767 0.700 0.936 0.874 0.795
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -83.8 -83.8 -81.8 -2.08 6.99 1.01 0.780 0.731 0.913 0.999 0.831
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] -51.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] -61.1 -62.2 -51.4 -10.8 11.8 0.898 0.452 0.712 0.911 0.950 0.747
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] -63.7 -63.8 -51.4 -12.4 14.1 0.998 0.404 0.611 0.905 0.993 0.705
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] -70.1 -70.1 -55.5 -14.5 16.1 0.992 0.310 0.623 0.913 0.995 0.693
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] -60.5 -61.5 -51.4 -10.1 11.2 0.704 0.472 0.715 0.905 0.953 0.752
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] -58.2 -58.4 -51.4 -7.01 9.68 1.30 0.604 0.620 0.855 0.986 0.737
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] -65.3 -65.3 -49.2 -16.2 18.4 1.51 0.203 0.428 0.781 0.998 0.567
CESM2_BARPA [-] -65.0 -65.9 -51.4 -14.5 15.7 0.800 0.333 0.656 0.899 0.930 0.695
CESM2_CCAM [-] -63.3 -63.7 -51.4 -12.3 13.4 1.21 0.394 0.682 0.812 0.951 0.704
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] -65.5 -66.3 -51.4 -14.9 16.0 0.704 0.326 0.663 0.905 0.977 0.707
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] -59.4 -60.0 -51.4 -8.58 9.48 0.704 0.532 0.769 0.905 0.942 0.783
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] -66.3 -66.3 -53.4 -12.9 14.3 1.02 0.395 0.644 0.825 0.995 0.701
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] -66.5 -66.8 -51.4 -15.4 16.6 0.901 0.323 0.645 0.881 0.998 0.698
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] -77.7 -77.7 -51.4 -26.3 27.9 0.326 0.104 0.459 0.979 0.622 0.525
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] -64.6 -65.5 -51.4 -14.1 16.0 0.702 0.341 0.568 0.906 0.911 0.659
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] -59.3 -59.9 -51.4 -8.46 10.5 1.00 0.524 0.625 0.874 0.972 0.724
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] -68.4 -67.5 -51.4 -16.1 20.9 0.800 0.289 0.376 0.899 0.990 0.586
ERA5_BARPA [-] -61.0 -62.0 -51.4 -10.6 11.9 0.704 0.448 0.671 0.905 0.951 0.729
ERA5_CCAM [-] -56.7 -57.4 -51.4 -5.94 6.93 0.704 0.644 0.812 0.905 0.955 0.826
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] -66.5 -67.6 -51.4 -16.2 17.3 0.607 0.297 0.651 0.912 0.990 0.700
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] -74.4 -76.0 -51.4 -24.6 25.7 0.704 0.156 0.574 0.905 0.915 0.625
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] -59.2 -60.5 -51.4 -9.05 11.2 0.704 0.501 0.621 0.905 0.893 0.708
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] -49.9 -50.4 -51.4 0.969 4.87 0.902 0.773 0.769 0.882 0.909 0.820
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] -56.8 -56.8 -53.4 -3.41 6.52 1.02 0.684 0.712 0.825 0.932 0.773

Temporally integrated period mean

BENCHMARK MEAN
Data not available
Data not available
MODEL MEAN
Data not available
BIAS
Data not available
BIAS SCORE
Data not available
Data not available
RMSE
Data not available
RMSE SCORE
Data not available
Data not available
BENCHMARK MAX MONTH
Data not available
Data not available
MODEL MAX MONTH
Data not available
Data not available
DIFFERENCE IN MAX MONTH
Data not available
SEASONAL CYCLE SCORE
Data not available

SPATIAL TAYLOR DIAGRAM
Data not available
MODEL COLORS
Data not available

Spatially integrated regional mean

MODEL COLORS
Data not available
REGIONAL MEAN
Data not available
ANNUAL CYCLE
Data not available
MONTHLY ANOMALY
Data not available
ANNUAL CYCLE
Data not available

All Models

Benchmark
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
CESM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
CESM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
ERA5_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ERA5_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available

Data Information

  Title:
CERES EBAF TOA and Surface Fluxes

  Institutions:
NASA Langley Research Center

  Source:
Monthly mean surface fluxes calculated by a radiative transfer model and constrained by the combined Terra and Aqua SSF1deg measurements

  History:
2019-06-25: downloaded source from https://ceres.larc.nasa.gov/products-info.php?product=EBAF
2019-08-13: converted to netCDF with https://github.com/mmu2019/Datasets/blob/master/read-rlns-ceres.py

  References:
Loeb, N.G., D.R. Doelling, H. Wang, W. Su, C. Nguyen, J.G. Corbett, L. Liang, C. Mitrescu, F.G. Rose, and S. Kato (2018), Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) Top-of-Atmosphere (TOA) Edition-4.0 Data Product, Journal of Climate, 31(2), 895-918, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0208.1

Kato, S., F. G. Rose, D. A. Rutan, T. E. Thorsen, N. G. Loeb, D. R. Doelling, X. Huang, W. L. Smith, W. Su, and S.-H. Ham (2018), Surface irradiances of Edition 4.0 Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) data product, Journal of Climate, 31, 4501-4527, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0523.1

  Comments:
time_period: 2000-01 through 2018-12
original_temporal_resolution: monthly
original_spatial_resolution: 1 degree
original_units: W m-2
final_temporal_resolution: monthly
final_spatial_resolution: 0.5 degree
final_units: W m-2

  Convention:
CF-1.7