Mean State

Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 40.6
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 48.6 47.8 40.6 7.17 7.82 0.773 0.517 0.750 0.932 0.997 0.789
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 42.2 41.6 40.6 0.995 3.38 0.616 0.832 0.779 0.952 0.999 0.868
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 45.3 45.3 40.0 5.28 6.42 0.718 0.604 0.760 0.941 0.965 0.806
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 49.3 48.5 40.6 7.85 8.33 0.737 0.488 0.766 0.942 0.998 0.792
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 41.8 41.2 40.6 0.563 3.22 0.614 0.835 0.788 0.952 0.999 0.872
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 48.3 48.3 40.1 8.17 9.63 0.760 0.476 0.663 0.939 0.925 0.733
CESM2_BARPA [-] 49.5 48.6 40.6 8.04 8.57 0.644 0.477 0.753 0.950 0.998 0.786
CESM2_CCAM [-] 43.1 42.5 40.6 1.94 3.84 0.780 0.788 0.765 0.938 0.996 0.850
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 49.6 48.8 40.6 8.16 8.86 0.852 0.473 0.726 0.919 0.998 0.768
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 40.2 39.6 40.6 -0.994 3.46 0.563 0.821 0.771 0.959 0.995 0.863
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 39.1 39.1 40.4 -1.33 4.73 0.727 0.774 0.705 0.936 0.998 0.824
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 41.6 41.0 40.6 0.387 2.82 0.597 0.867 0.802 0.951 0.999 0.884
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 40.8 40.8 40.2 0.646 4.56 0.699 0.708 0.800 0.927 0.976 0.842
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 49.8 49.0 40.6 8.37 8.78 0.692 0.465 0.775 0.944 0.998 0.791
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 41.5 40.9 40.6 0.335 3.40 0.627 0.830 0.771 0.950 0.999 0.864
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 45.0 44.7 40.6 4.11 6.76 0.792 0.621 0.700 0.924 0.993 0.788
ERA5_BARPA [-] 48.7 47.9 40.6 7.28 7.75 0.667 0.511 0.779 0.947 0.998 0.803
ERA5_CCAM [-] 41.6 41.0 40.6 0.373 2.89 0.506 0.835 0.819 0.960 0.999 0.886
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 50.4 49.6 40.6 8.97 9.44 0.828 0.441 0.756 0.925 0.997 0.775
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 49.4 48.7 40.6 8.10 8.91 0.725 0.482 0.753 0.940 0.996 0.785
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 47.8 47.0 40.6 6.40 7.57 0.751 0.553 0.700 0.925 0.997 0.775
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 39.4 38.8 40.6 -1.79 3.76 0.645 0.779 0.777 0.948 0.996 0.855
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 37.5 37.5 40.4 -2.88 5.19 0.625 0.722 0.753 0.948 0.976 0.831
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 33.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 41.4 41.4 33.7 7.69 8.06 0.927 0.496 0.780 0.938 0.957 0.791
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 35.7 35.7 33.7 1.94 2.52 0.250 0.835 0.860 0.983 0.999 0.913
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 34.7 34.7 34.0 0.752 2.77 1.03 0.868 0.836 0.921 0.789 0.852
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 41.8 41.8 33.7 8.04 8.20 0.963 0.481 0.826 0.935 0.945 0.800
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 35.3 35.3 33.7 1.55 2.79 0.505 0.868 0.810 0.941 1.00 0.894
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 36.5 36.5 33.7 2.87 5.05 1.34 0.708 0.761 0.865 0.996 0.825
CESM2_BARPA [-] 41.7 41.7 33.7 7.97 8.18 0.216 0.484 0.815 0.985 0.944 0.808
CESM2_CCAM [-] 36.5 36.5 33.7 2.73 3.70 1.25 0.779 0.790 0.884 0.996 0.854
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 42.1 42.1 33.7 8.36 8.65 0.781 0.467 0.790 0.947 0.943 0.787
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 34.1 34.1 33.7 0.389 3.30 0.599 0.933 0.743 0.960 0.996 0.889
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.6 32.6 33.7 -1.10 4.18 1.07 0.888 0.705 0.902 0.963 0.847
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 35.2 35.2 33.7 1.50 2.68 1.18 0.870 0.817 0.889 1.00 0.885
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 36.1 36.1 33.8 2.27 3.38 1.59 0.787 0.833 0.812 0.999 0.855
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 42.9 42.8 33.7 9.12 9.42 0.106 0.435 0.779 0.993 0.943 0.787
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 36.0 36.0 33.7 2.24 3.60 0.783 0.812 0.770 0.911 1.00 0.862
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 41.7 41.4 33.7 7.71 7.93 1.88 0.498 0.816 0.776 0.939 0.764
ERA5_BARPA [-] 41.5 41.5 33.7 7.80 8.02 0.244 0.491 0.815 0.984 0.954 0.811
ERA5_CCAM [-] 35.2 35.3 33.7 1.53 2.86 0.175 0.868 0.801 0.988 1.00 0.902
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 43.9 43.9 33.7 10.2 10.6 0.963 0.396 0.741 0.935 0.941 0.752
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 43.4 43.5 33.7 9.73 10.1 0.963 0.417 0.758 0.935 0.821 0.735
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 40.7 40.6 33.7 6.92 7.81 0.820 0.533 0.706 0.945 0.952 0.775
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 32.8 32.8 33.7 -0.916 2.87 0.963 0.906 0.792 0.935 0.999 0.895
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 32.8 32.8 33.7 -0.865 3.21 0.406 0.871 0.794 0.973 0.966 0.889
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 29.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 38.4 37.6 29.4 8.21 8.54 0.864 0.395 0.733 0.930 0.798 0.732
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 32.6 32.1 29.4 2.68 3.38 0.449 0.715 0.841 0.962 0.778 0.843
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 29.4 29.4 27.1 2.36 3.12 0.661 0.690 0.845 0.956 0.986 0.867
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 38.5 37.7 29.4 8.30 8.48 0.680 0.390 0.780 0.955 0.816 0.753
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 31.6 31.1 29.4 1.66 3.23 0.751 0.785 0.792 0.927 0.777 0.833
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 33.2 33.2 29.5 3.71 4.64 1.39 0.648 0.757 0.832 0.997 0.777
CESM2_BARPA [-] 38.6 37.8 29.4 8.39 8.60 0.819 0.381 0.773 0.929 0.869 0.750
CESM2_CCAM [-] 32.3 31.7 29.4 2.33 3.79 0.908 0.735 0.765 0.925 0.804 0.817
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 38.9 38.2 29.4 8.77 9.02 0.931 0.363 0.751 0.917 0.888 0.740
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 31.0 30.5 29.4 1.10 3.54 0.851 0.811 0.726 0.927 0.808 0.821
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 29.3 29.3 29.0 0.268 3.72 0.832 0.782 0.724 0.912 0.991 0.810
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 31.9 31.4 29.4 1.98 3.67 1.54 0.760 0.771 0.820 0.751 0.800
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 30.1 30.1 28.5 1.65 2.82 1.54 0.786 0.786 0.822 0.999 0.833
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 39.6 38.8 29.4 9.36 9.64 0.949 0.344 0.732 0.910 0.837 0.716
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 32.4 31.9 29.4 2.47 4.26 1.28 0.727 0.733 0.851 0.775 0.786
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 33.5 32.9 29.4 3.53 4.78 1.21 0.627 0.787 0.869 0.977 0.776
ERA5_BARPA [-] 38.5 37.7 29.4 8.28 8.51 0.838 0.389 0.764 0.916 0.837 0.744
ERA5_CCAM [-] 31.7 31.1 29.4 1.71 3.69 0.576 0.768 0.773 0.962 0.732 0.831
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 40.6 39.7 29.4 10.3 10.7 0.680 0.307 0.703 0.955 0.851 0.713
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 37.0 36.0 29.4 6.62 7.12 0.680 0.453 0.763 0.955 0.956 0.768
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 37.6 36.8 29.4 7.44 8.02 0.680 0.429 0.690 0.955 0.822 0.735
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 29.2 28.7 29.4 -0.739 3.91 0.783 0.718 0.749 0.948 0.596 0.797
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 28.9 28.9 29.0 -0.124 3.27 0.828 0.768 0.801 0.945 0.824 0.816
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 36.6
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 47.0 45.1 36.6 8.50 9.17 1.29 0.316 0.637 0.869 0.948 0.691
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 37.1 35.7 36.6 -0.903 3.93 1.01 0.759 0.637 0.917 0.971 0.814
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 42.0 42.0 35.7 6.32 7.15 1.06 0.412 0.642 0.903 0.960 0.724
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 47.5 45.6 36.6 8.97 9.56 0.914 0.296 0.646 0.921 0.947 0.701
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 36.3 35.0 36.6 -1.64 3.75 0.810 0.751 0.657 0.933 0.992 0.824
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 46.2 46.2 36.5 9.72 11.2 0.958 0.295 0.484 0.927 0.823 0.624
CESM2_BARPA [-] 48.3 46.3 36.6 9.69 10.3 0.914 0.270 0.629 0.922 0.938 0.688
CESM2_CCAM [-] 37.9 36.6 36.6 -0.0952 3.34 0.757 0.776 0.679 0.942 0.977 0.833
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 48.3 46.4 36.6 9.73 10.4 1.42 0.267 0.609 0.828 0.937 0.661
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 36.0 34.7 36.6 -1.96 3.68 0.529 0.720 0.668 0.961 0.997 0.828
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 36.0 36.0 36.8 -0.760 5.38 0.471 0.685 0.535 0.968 0.996 0.780
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 37.4 36.1 36.6 -0.567 3.04 0.433 0.805 0.697 0.967 0.989 0.854
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 38.3 38.3 36.3 2.05 3.90 0.449 0.633 0.734 0.958 0.917 0.786
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 47.7 45.8 36.6 9.15 9.55 0.731 0.290 0.711 0.938 0.937 0.721
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 35.7 34.4 36.6 -2.22 4.26 0.652 0.694 0.636 0.953 0.986 0.808
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 41.0 40.5 36.6 3.86 6.60 0.322 0.534 0.555 0.973 0.947 0.737
ERA5_BARPA [-] 47.2 45.3 36.6 8.67 9.24 0.913 0.309 0.654 0.920 0.945 0.705
ERA5_CCAM [-] 35.8 34.6 36.6 -2.07 3.54 0.547 0.718 0.701 0.958 0.990 0.835
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 48.8 46.9 36.6 10.2 10.7 1.24 0.251 0.664 0.858 0.927 0.677
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 51.6 50.3 36.6 13.7 14.3 0.762 0.183 0.616 0.930 0.896 0.652
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 46.3 44.5 36.6 7.85 8.77 1.59 0.347 0.597 0.809 0.953 0.675
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 34.0 32.8 36.6 -3.84 4.79 0.503 0.576 0.683 0.954 0.999 0.796
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 35.5 35.5 36.8 -1.22 3.81 0.480 0.667 0.758 0.955 0.939 0.829
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 37.3
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 44.8 44.7 37.3 7.44 7.89 0.143 0.632 0.824 0.988 0.986 0.854
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 37.9 37.9 37.3 0.605 2.76 0.119 0.887 0.885 0.992 0.995 0.934
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 39.5 39.5 36.8 2.63 4.60 0.468 0.798 0.854 0.963 0.800 0.854
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 45.7 45.7 37.3 8.41 8.73 0.916 0.596 0.832 0.938 0.986 0.837
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 38.3 38.2 37.3 0.924 2.80 0.353 0.895 0.878 0.974 0.996 0.929
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 36.4 36.4 36.4 0.00154 5.40 0.808 0.760 0.822 0.946 0.925 0.859
CESM2_BARPA [-] 44.7 44.7 37.3 7.40 7.79 0.0717 0.633 0.836 0.995 0.979 0.858
CESM2_CCAM [-] 38.4 38.4 37.3 1.12 3.21 0.591 0.872 0.870 0.960 0.998 0.919
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 45.2 45.2 37.3 7.91 8.37 0.870 0.615 0.820 0.942 0.978 0.836
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 36.9 36.9 37.3 -0.416 3.42 0.824 0.918 0.834 0.945 0.993 0.913
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.4 32.4 36.3 -3.91 5.96 0.710 0.781 0.770 0.943 0.977 0.857
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 37.2 37.2 37.3 -0.139 2.89 0.730 0.910 0.867 0.951 0.983 0.921
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 34.0 34.0 36.6 -2.68 3.97 0.954 0.840 0.864 0.936 0.999 0.904
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 46.1 46.1 37.3 8.81 9.06 0.985 0.580 0.839 0.931 0.991 0.836
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 37.7 37.7 37.3 0.404 3.38 0.537 0.907 0.837 0.959 0.990 0.914
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 43.7 43.9 37.3 6.64 7.35 1.05 0.666 0.829 0.918 0.904 0.829
ERA5_BARPA [-] 44.6 44.6 37.3 7.29 7.58 0.684 0.637 0.851 0.954 0.991 0.857
ERA5_CCAM [-] 37.9 37.9 37.3 0.552 2.91 0.493 0.906 0.867 0.967 0.992 0.926
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 45.8 45.8 37.3 8.48 8.90 0.939 0.594 0.819 0.937 0.978 0.831
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 43.9 44.0 37.3 6.68 7.71 0.962 0.654 0.816 0.935 0.816 0.807
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 43.9 43.9 37.3 6.56 7.32 0.309 0.665 0.801 0.979 0.991 0.853
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 36.7 36.7 37.3 -0.652 2.90 0.613 0.910 0.866 0.959 0.991 0.924
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 32.5 32.5 36.3 -3.82 6.01 0.314 0.783 0.769 0.980 0.993 0.869
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 45.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 52.0 51.7 45.1 6.55 7.25 0.722 0.581 0.777 0.939 0.998 0.823
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 46.6 46.3 45.1 1.19 3.24 0.617 0.871 0.797 0.953 0.999 0.899
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 51.4 51.4 45.1 6.28 7.24 0.706 0.603 0.764 0.943 0.973 0.819
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 52.8 52.4 45.1 7.31 7.81 0.701 0.547 0.792 0.943 0.998 0.820
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 46.3 45.9 45.1 0.836 3.06 0.616 0.868 0.813 0.954 0.999 0.903
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 54.8 54.8 44.8 9.97 11.0 0.664 0.448 0.674 0.950 0.952 0.757
CESM2_BARPA [-] 53.1 52.7 45.1 7.62 8.17 0.662 0.528 0.777 0.950 0.998 0.813
CESM2_CCAM [-] 48.0 47.7 45.1 2.60 4.13 0.801 0.790 0.770 0.936 0.997 0.868
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 53.2 52.8 45.1 7.70 8.50 0.756 0.527 0.739 0.934 0.997 0.798
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 44.1 43.7 45.1 -1.35 3.33 0.555 0.840 0.800 0.960 0.999 0.895
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 43.4 43.4 44.9 -1.45 4.56 0.828 0.797 0.740 0.925 0.998 0.858
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 45.8 45.5 45.1 0.416 2.54 0.552 0.904 0.831 0.956 1.00 0.918
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 45.5 45.5 45.2 0.309 5.12 0.702 0.705 0.809 0.922 0.925 0.832
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 53.4 53.0 45.1 7.93 8.36 0.718 0.519 0.795 0.942 0.997 0.814
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 46.1 45.8 45.1 0.662 2.99 0.615 0.881 0.806 0.954 0.999 0.904
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 49.3 49.1 45.1 4.00 6.97 0.851 0.647 0.706 0.918 0.892 0.790
ERA5_BARPA [-] 52.2 51.8 45.1 6.72 7.18 0.649 0.573 0.810 0.951 0.998 0.833
ERA5_CCAM [-] 46.1 45.8 45.1 0.725 2.49 0.528 0.877 0.857 0.956 0.999 0.919
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 54.0 53.7 45.1 8.56 9.01 0.748 0.491 0.784 0.935 0.996 0.804
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 52.3 51.9 45.1 6.85 7.64 0.714 0.545 0.788 0.939 0.983 0.813
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 51.2 50.8 45.1 5.75 7.16 0.596 0.620 0.714 0.944 0.998 0.815
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 43.6 43.3 45.1 -1.81 3.56 0.701 0.824 0.795 0.942 0.998 0.887
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 41.0 41.0 44.9 -3.89 5.89 0.702 0.714 0.743 0.941 0.988 0.842
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 21.8
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 33.7 31.3 21.8 9.50 10.4 0.206 0.405 0.645 0.986 0.961 0.701
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 28.5 26.7 21.8 4.92 5.85 0.307 0.589 0.787 0.979 0.931 0.818
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 20.5 20.5 19.5 1.06 4.47 0.240 0.639 0.814 0.984 0.983 0.830
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 34.7 32.2 21.8 10.5 11.3 0.620 0.372 0.627 0.958 0.972 0.679
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 27.9 26.2 21.8 4.45 5.38 0.359 0.611 0.808 0.976 0.968 0.828
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 23.1 23.1 20.7 2.40 4.15 0.398 0.640 0.810 0.973 0.815 0.755
CESM2_BARPA [-] 33.2 31.0 21.8 9.20 10.1 0.361 0.415 0.651 0.976 0.957 0.701
CESM2_CCAM [-] 27.1 25.5 21.8 3.71 5.19 0.413 0.623 0.811 0.972 0.953 0.839
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 33.4 31.1 21.8 9.34 10.2 0.464 0.410 0.657 0.969 0.964 0.696
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 27.6 25.9 21.8 4.15 5.03 0.464 0.628 0.831 0.969 0.919 0.832
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 19.3 19.3 20.9 -1.61 3.82 0.318 0.787 0.742 0.979 0.961 0.834
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 27.8 26.0 21.8 4.25 5.29 0.519 0.618 0.803 0.965 0.953 0.825
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 18.3 18.3 17.4 0.950 3.00 0.352 0.734 0.832 0.976 0.628 0.836
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 35.3 32.8 21.8 11.1 11.9 0.624 0.354 0.621 0.958 0.963 0.669
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 27.9 26.1 21.8 4.35 5.33 0.570 0.615 0.806 0.962 0.937 0.824
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 24.5 24.1 21.8 2.29 4.82 0.835 0.667 0.811 0.926 0.891 0.824
ERA5_BARPA [-] 33.7 31.3 21.8 9.56 10.4 0.412 0.404 0.650 0.972 0.954 0.694
ERA5_CCAM [-] 28.2 26.4 21.8 4.63 5.49 0.517 0.601 0.823 0.965 0.926 0.821
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 34.2 31.7 21.8 9.96 10.9 0.568 0.390 0.625 0.962 0.978 0.681
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 27.2 24.7 21.8 2.91 4.81 0.573 0.694 0.750 0.961 0.984 0.787
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 33.1 30.7 21.8 8.97 9.82 0.461 0.424 0.655 0.969 0.943 0.703
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 27.3 25.6 21.8 3.83 5.20 0.567 0.632 0.785 0.962 0.919 0.825
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 21.2 21.2 20.9 0.270 3.57 0.633 0.785 0.769 0.958 0.868 0.822
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 37.0
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 45.5 43.4 37.0 6.38 7.20 0.367 0.641 0.815 0.975 0.996 0.850
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 40.4 39.1 37.0 2.07 3.39 0.340 0.842 0.857 0.977 0.999 0.913
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 38.1 38.1 34.8 3.28 4.75 0.0593 0.753 0.852 0.996 0.988 0.888
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 46.6 44.5 37.0 7.43 7.99 0.315 0.604 0.830 0.979 0.993 0.847
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 39.8 38.5 37.0 1.48 3.15 0.288 0.869 0.858 0.981 0.999 0.919
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 39.5 39.5 35.9 3.63 5.93 0.128 0.732 0.817 0.991 0.996 0.883
CESM2_BARPA [-] 45.7 43.6 37.0 6.57 7.29 0.476 0.634 0.827 0.968 0.988 0.852
CESM2_CCAM [-] 39.5 38.3 37.0 1.28 2.83 0.580 0.880 0.861 0.961 0.999 0.918
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 45.8 43.7 37.0 6.67 7.24 0.262 0.631 0.844 0.982 0.988 0.856
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 38.3 37.1 37.0 0.0964 3.67 0.367 0.907 0.811 0.975 0.995 0.909
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 33.8 33.8 35.9 -2.14 4.63 0.247 0.801 0.806 0.983 0.981 0.871
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 38.0 36.8 37.0 -0.223 3.30 0.263 0.899 0.833 0.982 0.992 0.914
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 35.4 35.4 34.8 0.511 4.41 0.203 0.773 0.833 0.986 0.996 0.885
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 46.6 44.5 37.0 7.41 7.96 0.341 0.606 0.826 0.977 0.996 0.844
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 39.0 37.8 37.0 0.721 3.32 0.237 0.889 0.837 0.984 0.995 0.914
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 40.3 39.9 37.0 2.84 6.69 0.341 0.692 0.795 0.977 0.911 0.848
ERA5_BARPA [-] 45.4 43.3 37.0 6.23 6.80 0.341 0.647 0.856 0.977 0.994 0.863
ERA5_CCAM [-] 39.4 38.1 37.0 1.10 3.20 0.315 0.880 0.851 0.979 0.998 0.918
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 46.3 44.2 37.0 7.15 7.88 0.341 0.611 0.816 0.977 0.990 0.843
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 45.7 41.7 37.0 4.69 6.14 0.341 0.717 0.809 0.977 0.932 0.865
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 44.7 42.6 37.0 5.60 6.51 0.288 0.671 0.822 0.981 0.995 0.861
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 38.5 37.3 37.0 0.271 2.97 0.315 0.897 0.856 0.979 0.997 0.922
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 33.1 33.1 35.9 -2.85 5.52 0.472 0.792 0.778 0.968 0.982 0.857
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 28.0
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 41.5 37.6 28.0 9.51 9.87 0.614 0.266 0.703 0.959 0.954 0.719
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 29.8 27.6 28.0 -0.474 3.37 0.614 0.709 0.694 0.959 0.861 0.794
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 26.8 26.8 24.5 2.31 4.17 1.02 0.535 0.715 0.933 0.719 0.724
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 41.5 37.6 28.0 9.54 9.82 0.614 0.264 0.727 0.959 0.954 0.726
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 29.0 26.9 28.0 -1.11 3.25 0.614 0.696 0.725 0.959 0.820 0.792
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 30.0 30.0 23.6 6.41 7.35 1.02 0.365 0.544 0.933 0.946 0.680
CESM2_BARPA [-] 42.4 38.2 28.0 10.2 10.5 0.512 0.243 0.724 0.966 0.963 0.724
CESM2_CCAM [-] 29.7 27.5 28.0 -0.595 3.35 0.614 0.689 0.717 0.959 0.800 0.783
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 42.6 38.5 28.0 10.4 10.7 0.303 0.232 0.731 0.980 0.963 0.727
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 29.4 27.3 28.0 -0.735 3.40 0.102 0.701 0.700 0.993 0.810 0.790
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 30.4 30.4 26.9 3.50 4.88 0.680 0.577 0.636 0.955 0.968 0.768
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 30.5 28.3 28.0 0.263 3.23 0.813 0.739 0.697 0.946 0.858 0.798
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 29.5 29.5 24.8 4.68 5.06 0.169 0.394 0.696 0.989 0.969 0.755
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 41.9 37.8 28.0 9.72 9.92 0.306 0.257 0.771 0.980 0.956 0.744
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 28.3 26.2 28.0 -1.86 3.90 0.307 0.686 0.668 0.980 0.803 0.771
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 31.6 29.4 28.0 1.33 5.17 0.512 0.542 0.676 0.966 0.991 0.781
ERA5_BARPA [-] 41.0 37.1 28.0 9.07 9.41 0.511 0.281 0.727 0.966 0.942 0.729
ERA5_CCAM [-] 28.4 26.3 28.0 -1.71 3.65 0.304 0.688 0.696 0.980 0.784 0.777
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 42.6 38.6 28.0 10.6 10.8 0.711 0.227 0.741 0.953 0.969 0.724
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 42.5 45.0 28.0 17.0 17.2 0.713 0.144 0.628 0.953 0.965 0.667
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 40.6 36.6 28.0 8.60 9.08 0.199 0.302 0.687 0.987 0.940 0.724
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 26.3 24.4 28.0 -3.63 5.09 0.304 0.597 0.636 0.980 0.701 0.718
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 28.5 28.5 26.9 1.57 3.37 0.904 0.651 0.748 0.940 0.997 0.824
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 15.2
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 16.8 17.0 15.2 11.7 1.75 2.59 1.02 0.646 0.710 0.863 0.943 0.774
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 14.6 14.8 15.4 9.99 -0.577 2.01 1.14 0.568 0.686 0.836 0.990 0.753
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 16.3 16.5 15.3 11.4 1.21 1.89 1.12 0.683 0.716 0.846 0.972 0.787
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 17.1 17.3 15.2 11.7 2.12 2.72 1.12 0.664 0.706 0.844 0.937 0.771
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 14.5 14.7 15.4 9.99 -0.682 1.85 1.15 0.604 0.679 0.836 0.993 0.758
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 17.9 18.2 15.4 12.7 2.79 3.30 1.13 0.373 0.685 0.841 0.958 0.708
CESM2_BARPA [-] 16.5 16.8 15.2 11.7 1.55 2.86 0.886 0.572 0.680 0.889 0.930 0.750
CESM2_CCAM [-] 14.8 15.0 15.4 9.99 -0.391 1.95 0.999 0.579 0.701 0.875 0.986 0.769
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 16.7 16.9 15.2 11.7 1.69 2.88 0.873 0.586 0.701 0.894 0.927 0.762
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 14.7 14.8 15.4 9.99 -0.552 1.80 0.998 0.600 0.704 0.878 0.993 0.776
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 14.3 14.4 15.2 10.6 -0.807 1.85 0.874 0.640 0.695 0.903 0.992 0.785
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 14.6 14.8 15.4 9.99 -0.590 1.72 1.21 0.631 0.683 0.832 0.994 0.764
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 15.6 15.9 15.4 10.7 0.542 1.68 1.07 0.688 0.693 0.852 0.991 0.783
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 16.9 17.1 15.2 11.7 1.93 3.04 1.00 0.547 0.686 0.871 0.930 0.744
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 14.6 14.7 15.4 9.99 -0.669 1.94 1.15 0.586 0.678 0.846 0.993 0.756
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 15.5 15.6 15.3 6.56 0.346 2.37 1.04 0.567 0.698 0.864 0.970 0.759
ERA5_BARPA [-] 16.8 17.0 15.2 11.7 1.75 2.55 0.715 0.636 0.749 0.914 0.939 0.798
ERA5_CCAM [-] 14.8 15.0 15.4 9.99 -0.381 1.59 0.813 0.619 0.759 0.890 0.993 0.804
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 17.0 17.2 15.2 11.7 2.01 2.92 0.991 0.604 0.700 0.872 0.922 0.759
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 17.2 17.3 15.2 2.17 2.65 0.951 0.560 0.717 0.884 0.949 0.765
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 16.2 16.4 15.2 11.7 1.23 2.79 0.950 0.549 0.671 0.874 0.946 0.742
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 14.2 14.4 15.4 9.99 -1.00 1.90 1.00 0.578 0.707 0.875 0.992 0.771
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 14.1 14.2 15.2 10.5 -0.991 1.90 0.795 0.585 0.740 0.901 0.988 0.791
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 13.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 15.7 15.8 13.8 11.8 1.94 3.45 1.76 0.471 0.544 0.738 0.692 0.598
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 11.7 11.8 13.8 11.8 -2.03 2.82 1.86 0.279 0.513 0.712 0.993 0.602
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 14.4 14.4 13.7 0.640 1.69 1.86 0.613 0.555 0.727 0.961 0.682
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 16.3 16.4 13.8 11.8 2.55 3.54 1.91 0.566 0.534 0.718 0.683 0.607
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 12.0 12.0 13.8 11.8 -1.82 2.68 1.80 0.301 0.505 0.726 0.993 0.606
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 15.6 15.7 13.8 14.6 1.89 2.70 2.00 0.275 0.512 0.696 0.984 0.596
CESM2_BARPA [-] 15.2 15.4 13.8 11.8 1.52 3.85 1.66 0.346 0.513 0.764 0.673 0.562
CESM2_CCAM [-] 12.9 13.0 13.8 11.8 -0.843 2.58 1.84 0.350 0.543 0.721 0.964 0.624
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 15.6 15.8 13.8 11.8 1.92 3.91 1.49 0.367 0.550 0.781 0.655 0.581
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 12.6 12.7 13.8 11.8 -1.18 2.30 1.54 0.361 0.576 0.786 0.991 0.658
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 12.9 13.0 13.8 11.5 -0.852 2.13 1.30 0.425 0.605 0.827 0.989 0.690
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 12.4 12.4 13.8 11.8 -1.42 2.44 2.13 0.348 0.498 0.669 0.993 0.601
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 14.4 14.6 13.9 12.3 0.677 1.86 1.93 0.580 0.503 0.696 0.978 0.652
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 15.6 15.7 13.8 11.8 1.86 3.75 1.71 0.407 0.533 0.743 0.674 0.578
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 12.0 12.0 13.8 11.8 -1.81 2.71 1.90 0.293 0.523 0.720 0.993 0.610
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 13.7 13.8 13.7 0.0162 2.84 1.82 0.344 0.533 0.721 0.914 0.609
ERA5_BARPA [-] 15.9 16.1 13.8 11.8 2.22 3.48 1.25 0.471 0.619 0.818 0.684 0.642
ERA5_CCAM [-] 12.7 12.8 13.8 11.8 -1.03 2.14 1.54 0.380 0.625 0.770 0.993 0.679
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 16.0 16.1 13.8 11.8 2.31 3.72 1.74 0.469 0.512 0.742 0.670 0.581
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 16.0 16.0 13.7 2.30 3.05 1.54 0.414 0.564 0.792 0.825 0.632
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 14.9 15.0 13.8 11.8 1.14 3.83 1.85 0.294 0.508 0.724 0.689 0.545
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 12.0 12.0 13.8 11.8 -1.80 2.58 1.77 0.316 0.551 0.746 0.969 0.627
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 13.4 13.5 13.8 11.8 -0.333 2.06 1.45 0.419 0.601 0.789 0.943 0.670
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 33.7
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 41.4 41.4 33.7 7.69 8.06 0.927 0.496 0.780 0.938 0.957 0.790
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 35.7 35.7 33.7 1.94 2.52 0.250 0.835 0.860 0.983 0.999 0.907
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 34.7 34.7 34.0 0.752 2.77 1.03 0.868 0.836 0.921 0.789 0.850
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 41.8 41.8 33.7 8.04 8.20 0.963 0.481 0.826 0.935 0.945 0.803
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 35.3 35.3 33.7 1.55 2.79 0.505 0.868 0.810 0.941 1.00 0.886
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 36.5 36.5 33.7 2.87 5.05 1.34 0.708 0.761 0.865 0.996 0.818
CESM2_BARPA [-] 41.7 41.7 33.7 7.97 8.18 0.216 0.484 0.815 0.985 0.944 0.809
CESM2_CCAM [-] 36.5 36.5 33.7 2.73 3.70 1.25 0.779 0.790 0.884 0.996 0.847
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 42.1 42.1 33.7 8.36 8.65 0.781 0.467 0.790 0.947 0.943 0.788
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 34.1 34.1 33.7 0.389 3.30 0.599 0.933 0.743 0.960 0.996 0.875
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.6 32.6 33.7 -1.10 4.18 1.07 0.888 0.705 0.902 0.963 0.832
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 35.2 35.2 33.7 1.50 2.68 1.18 0.870 0.817 0.889 1.00 0.878
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 36.1 36.1 33.8 2.27 3.38 1.59 0.787 0.833 0.812 0.999 0.853
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 42.9 42.8 33.7 9.12 9.42 0.106 0.435 0.779 0.993 0.943 0.786
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 36.0 36.0 33.7 2.24 3.60 0.783 0.812 0.770 0.911 1.00 0.853
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 41.7 41.4 33.7 7.71 7.93 1.88 0.498 0.816 0.776 0.939 0.769
ERA5_BARPA [-] 41.5 41.5 33.7 7.80 8.02 0.244 0.491 0.815 0.984 0.954 0.812
ERA5_CCAM [-] 35.2 35.3 33.7 1.53 2.86 0.175 0.868 0.801 0.988 1.00 0.892
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 43.9 43.9 33.7 10.2 10.6 0.963 0.396 0.741 0.935 0.941 0.751
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 43.4 43.5 33.7 9.73 10.1 0.963 0.417 0.758 0.935 0.821 0.738
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 40.7 40.6 33.7 6.92 7.81 0.820 0.533 0.706 0.945 0.952 0.768
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 32.8 32.8 33.7 -0.916 2.87 0.963 0.906 0.792 0.935 0.999 0.885
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 32.8 32.8 33.7 -0.865 3.21 0.406 0.871 0.794 0.973 0.966 0.880
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 31.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 38.9 38.4 31.9 6.52 6.80 0.976 0.481 0.781 0.917 0.958 0.783
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 33.4 33.2 31.9 1.32 2.31 0.612 0.827 0.839 0.948 0.979 0.886
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 30.8 30.8 28.8 2.02 3.03 0.816 0.716 0.839 0.946 0.986 0.865
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 39.0 38.5 31.9 6.64 6.77 0.561 0.474 0.830 0.963 0.980 0.815
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 32.4 32.2 31.9 0.341 2.51 0.663 0.894 0.777 0.944 0.973 0.873
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 34.1 34.1 30.8 3.28 4.29 0.796 0.677 0.771 0.947 0.999 0.833
CESM2_BARPA [-] 39.3 38.9 31.9 7.01 7.21 0.717 0.454 0.803 0.940 0.986 0.797
CESM2_CCAM [-] 33.0 32.8 31.9 0.924 2.92 0.662 0.849 0.756 0.956 0.998 0.863
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 39.8 39.3 31.9 7.45 7.70 0.931 0.431 0.780 0.908 0.994 0.779
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 32.0 31.8 31.9 -0.0729 3.16 0.764 0.903 0.713 0.932 0.982 0.848
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.0 32.0 31.1 0.863 3.53 1.02 0.786 0.750 0.883 0.981 0.830
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 32.6 32.4 31.9 0.508 2.92 1.73 0.880 0.745 0.788 0.980 0.827
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 32.0 32.0 30.3 1.69 2.80 1.75 0.804 0.780 0.787 0.999 0.830
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 40.1 39.6 31.9 7.75 7.94 0.766 0.418 0.795 0.943 0.980 0.786
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 33.2 32.9 31.9 1.07 3.61 0.965 0.841 0.694 0.892 0.979 0.820
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 35.2 34.9 31.9 2.99 4.33 0.865 0.676 0.790 0.919 0.793 0.794
ERA5_BARPA [-] 39.1 38.6 31.9 6.74 6.93 1.18 0.468 0.813 0.879 0.974 0.789
ERA5_CCAM [-] 32.3 32.1 31.9 0.204 3.06 0.458 0.885 0.729 0.970 0.966 0.856
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 41.0 40.6 31.9 8.68 8.94 0.561 0.376 0.760 0.963 0.986 0.769
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 39.5 38.9 31.9 6.97 7.24 0.561 0.457 0.782 0.963 0.998 0.797
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 38.2 37.8 31.9 5.88 6.44 0.561 0.517 0.733 0.963 0.978 0.785
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 29.5 29.3 31.9 -2.61 3.94 0.713 0.751 0.725 0.953 0.928 0.816
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 30.2 30.2 31.1 -0.917 3.41 0.781 0.751 0.807 0.948 0.958 0.854
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 24.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 37.5 35.9 24.1 11.8 12.2 0.626 0.211 0.630 0.958 0.998 0.685
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 30.9 29.7 24.1 5.58 5.67 0.102 0.477 0.844 0.993 0.913 0.814
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 25.8 25.8 22.5 3.25 3.36 0.253 0.619 0.862 0.983 0.995 0.864
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 37.5 35.9 24.1 11.8 12.1 0.932 0.210 0.674 0.937 0.998 0.698
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 29.8 28.6 24.1 4.48 4.74 0.939 0.552 0.825 0.889 0.897 0.798
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 30.9 30.9 26.2 4.74 5.47 2.82 0.579 0.724 0.556 0.855 0.687
CESM2_BARPA [-] 37.0 35.4 24.1 11.3 11.5 1.04 0.225 0.709 0.907 0.997 0.709
CESM2_CCAM [-] 30.7 29.4 24.1 5.33 5.64 1.43 0.493 0.783 0.858 0.929 0.769
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 37.2 35.7 24.1 11.6 11.8 0.932 0.218 0.689 0.937 0.996 0.706
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 28.9 27.7 24.1 3.61 4.37 1.04 0.617 0.756 0.918 0.858 0.781
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 23.9 23.9 24.8 -0.931 4.11 0.454 0.775 0.671 0.969 0.584 0.734
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 30.5 29.2 24.1 5.13 5.27 1.13 0.506 0.828 0.889 0.911 0.792
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 25.6 25.6 24.1 1.56 2.85 1.04 0.742 0.801 0.906 0.831 0.816
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 38.5 36.9 24.1 12.8 13.3 1.34 0.186 0.599 0.839 0.994 0.644
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 30.9 29.6 24.1 5.45 5.65 1.95 0.483 0.817 0.763 0.928 0.762
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 29.9 28.8 24.1 4.69 5.74 1.95 0.522 0.780 0.763 0.796 0.728
ERA5_BARPA [-] 37.2 35.6 24.1 11.5 11.9 0.0997 0.219 0.660 0.993 0.997 0.706
ERA5_CCAM [-] 30.3 29.0 24.1 4.91 5.04 0.829 0.521 0.867 0.944 0.908 0.821
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 39.7 38.0 24.1 13.9 14.4 0.932 0.161 0.581 0.937 0.986 0.649
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 31.9 30.0 24.1 5.87 6.88 0.932 0.445 0.722 0.937 0.785 0.722
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 36.4 34.9 24.1 10.8 11.4 0.932 0.242 0.599 0.937 0.999 0.675
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 28.5 27.4 24.1 3.25 3.84 0.932 0.649 0.800 0.937 0.863 0.810
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 26.3 26.3 24.8 1.47 3.00 0.921 0.804 0.787 0.938 0.483 0.760
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 38.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 49.4 48.0 38.9 9.09 9.66 0.973 0.361 0.699 0.919 0.988 0.733
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 40.9 39.8 38.9 0.919 3.41 0.764 0.840 0.714 0.945 0.999 0.842
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 43.7 43.7 38.0 5.65 6.85 1.23 0.537 0.693 0.876 0.938 0.747
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 49.6 48.2 38.9 9.31 9.72 0.635 0.352 0.734 0.953 0.988 0.752
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 39.2 38.2 38.9 -0.714 3.27 0.595 0.837 0.723 0.958 0.998 0.848
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 46.5 46.5 38.4 8.11 9.40 0.762 0.423 0.623 0.944 0.816 0.686
CESM2_BARPA [-] 50.6 49.1 38.9 10.2 10.7 0.700 0.318 0.697 0.946 0.983 0.728
CESM2_CCAM [-] 40.4 39.4 38.9 0.481 3.41 0.595 0.828 0.718 0.958 0.996 0.844
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 50.9 49.5 38.9 10.5 11.0 0.974 0.305 0.689 0.909 0.983 0.715
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 39.0 38.1 38.9 -0.855 3.18 0.574 0.839 0.728 0.959 0.996 0.850
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 38.6 38.6 39.0 -0.425 4.76 0.547 0.768 0.634 0.964 0.997 0.799
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 40.3 39.4 38.9 0.436 2.83 0.509 0.862 0.752 0.964 0.999 0.866
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 38.6 38.6 38.3 0.302 3.60 0.674 0.722 0.794 0.944 0.555 0.762
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 50.3 48.9 38.9 9.95 10.2 0.595 0.326 0.771 0.958 0.987 0.763
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 38.9 38.0 38.9 -0.936 3.83 0.574 0.814 0.684 0.959 0.999 0.828
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 44.7 44.0 38.9 5.12 7.75 0.297 0.542 0.557 0.978 0.998 0.726
ERA5_BARPA [-] 49.5 48.1 38.9 9.19 9.65 0.699 0.355 0.720 0.941 0.987 0.745
ERA5_CCAM [-] 38.5 37.6 38.9 -1.28 3.09 0.596 0.806 0.761 0.954 0.999 0.856
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 51.5 50.0 38.9 11.1 11.5 1.12 0.285 0.715 0.896 0.980 0.718
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 53.0 52.3 38.9 13.4 14.2 1.10 0.227 0.658 0.898 0.892 0.667
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 48.6 47.3 38.9 8.33 9.12 1.10 0.393 0.666 0.905 0.991 0.724
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 36.0 35.1 38.9 -3.77 4.96 0.445 0.636 0.708 0.962 0.996 0.802
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 35.8 35.8 39.0 -3.21 4.48 0.468 0.667 0.796 0.960 0.951 0.834
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 35.1
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 45.4 43.2 35.1 8.09 8.83 1.50 0.285 0.594 0.835 0.901 0.642
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 34.5 32.9 35.1 -2.15 4.28 1.18 0.704 0.584 0.898 0.976 0.749
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 40.9 40.9 34.2 6.76 7.35 0.946 0.332 0.609 0.921 0.951 0.684
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 46.1 43.8 35.1 8.74 9.45 1.10 0.258 0.586 0.900 0.891 0.644
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 34.4 32.8 35.1 -2.27 4.07 0.957 0.693 0.612 0.916 0.985 0.764
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 46.0 46.0 35.2 10.8 12.4 1.09 0.211 0.393 0.916 0.777 0.538
CESM2_BARPA [-] 46.7 44.4 35.1 9.33 10.0 1.06 0.237 0.582 0.906 0.882 0.638
CESM2_CCAM [-] 36.3 34.6 35.1 -0.489 3.29 0.868 0.741 0.653 0.931 0.956 0.787
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 46.6 44.3 35.1 9.19 9.98 1.72 0.242 0.555 0.773 0.889 0.603
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 33.9 32.4 35.1 -2.71 4.03 0.499 0.640 0.627 0.962 0.997 0.771
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 34.2 34.2 35.2 -0.990 5.80 0.418 0.628 0.468 0.970 0.991 0.705
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 35.5 33.8 35.1 -1.25 3.18 0.382 0.765 0.659 0.969 0.982 0.807
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 38.2 38.2 35.0 3.14 4.10 0.308 0.577 0.697 0.967 0.991 0.786
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 46.0 43.7 35.1 8.60 9.07 0.823 0.266 0.671 0.924 0.883 0.683
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 33.5 32.0 35.1 -3.09 4.55 0.706 0.612 0.603 0.948 0.984 0.750
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 38.7 38.1 35.1 3.00 5.82 0.339 0.529 0.553 0.969 0.888 0.699
ERA5_BARPA [-] 45.7 43.4 35.1 8.31 8.97 1.06 0.277 0.609 0.906 0.892 0.659
ERA5_CCAM [-] 34.0 32.5 35.1 -2.61 3.84 0.513 0.659 0.659 0.961 0.981 0.784
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 47.1 44.7 35.1 9.62 10.1 1.32 0.228 0.629 0.831 0.874 0.638
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 50.6 48.9 35.1 13.9 14.4 0.531 0.153 0.587 0.952 0.863 0.629
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 44.8 42.6 35.1 7.53 8.53 1.93 0.315 0.550 0.744 0.904 0.613
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 32.7 31.2 35.1 -3.88 4.68 0.543 0.534 0.666 0.949 0.995 0.762
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 35.3 35.3 35.2 0.140 3.35 0.489 0.667 0.732 0.952 0.970 0.811
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 37.3
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 44.8 44.7 37.3 7.44 7.89 0.143 0.632 0.824 0.988 0.986 0.851
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 37.9 37.9 37.3 0.605 2.76 0.119 0.887 0.885 0.992 0.995 0.929
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 39.5 39.5 36.8 2.63 4.60 0.468 0.798 0.854 0.963 0.800 0.854
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 45.7 45.7 37.3 8.41 8.73 0.916 0.596 0.832 0.938 0.986 0.837
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 38.3 38.2 37.3 0.924 2.80 0.353 0.895 0.878 0.974 0.996 0.924
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 36.4 36.4 36.4 0.00154 5.40 0.808 0.760 0.822 0.946 0.925 0.855
CESM2_BARPA [-] 44.7 44.7 37.3 7.40 7.79 0.0717 0.633 0.836 0.995 0.979 0.856
CESM2_CCAM [-] 38.4 38.4 37.3 1.12 3.21 0.591 0.872 0.870 0.960 0.998 0.914
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 45.2 45.2 37.3 7.91 8.37 0.870 0.615 0.820 0.942 0.978 0.835
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 36.9 36.9 37.3 -0.416 3.42 0.824 0.918 0.834 0.945 0.993 0.905
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.4 32.4 36.3 -3.91 5.96 0.710 0.781 0.770 0.943 0.977 0.848
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 37.2 37.2 37.3 -0.139 2.89 0.730 0.910 0.867 0.951 0.983 0.916
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 34.0 34.0 36.6 -2.68 3.97 0.954 0.840 0.864 0.936 0.999 0.900
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 46.1 46.1 37.3 8.81 9.06 0.985 0.580 0.839 0.931 0.991 0.836
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 37.7 37.7 37.3 0.404 3.38 0.537 0.907 0.837 0.959 0.990 0.906
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 43.7 43.9 37.3 6.64 7.35 1.05 0.666 0.829 0.918 0.904 0.829
ERA5_BARPA [-] 44.6 44.6 37.3 7.29 7.58 0.684 0.637 0.851 0.954 0.991 0.857
ERA5_CCAM [-] 37.9 37.9 37.3 0.552 2.91 0.493 0.906 0.867 0.967 0.992 0.920
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 45.8 45.8 37.3 8.48 8.90 0.939 0.594 0.819 0.937 0.978 0.830
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 43.9 44.0 37.3 6.68 7.71 0.962 0.654 0.816 0.935 0.816 0.807
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 43.9 43.9 37.3 6.56 7.32 0.309 0.665 0.801 0.979 0.991 0.847
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 36.7 36.7 37.3 -0.652 2.90 0.613 0.910 0.866 0.959 0.991 0.919
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 32.5 32.5 36.3 -3.82 6.01 0.314 0.783 0.769 0.980 0.993 0.859
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 47.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 53.9 53.9 47.4 6.52 7.26 0.943 0.563 0.761 0.916 0.998 0.800
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 48.3 48.3 47.4 0.854 3.62 0.764 0.877 0.752 0.939 0.999 0.864
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 53.5 53.5 47.3 6.24 7.37 0.893 0.592 0.735 0.925 0.952 0.788
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 54.7 54.7 47.4 7.25 7.80 0.904 0.528 0.774 0.923 0.997 0.799
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 47.7 47.6 47.4 0.242 3.34 0.758 0.875 0.770 0.942 0.999 0.871
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 57.9 57.9 47.0 10.9 12.2 0.818 0.399 0.604 0.936 0.934 0.695
CESM2_BARPA [-] 55.2 55.2 47.4 7.81 8.35 0.786 0.500 0.764 0.938 0.998 0.793
CESM2_CCAM [-] 50.0 49.9 47.4 2.53 4.40 0.923 0.785 0.730 0.921 0.998 0.833
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 55.4 55.4 47.4 7.95 8.75 0.998 0.496 0.722 0.908 0.997 0.769
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 45.7 45.6 47.4 -1.78 3.73 0.666 0.802 0.773 0.951 0.999 0.860
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 45.2 45.2 47.1 -1.95 5.12 0.810 0.770 0.685 0.919 0.999 0.812
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 47.8 47.8 47.4 0.413 2.87 0.708 0.890 0.801 0.942 0.999 0.887
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 47.1 47.1 47.1 0.0159 5.06 0.907 0.697 0.803 0.893 0.941 0.827
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 55.4 55.4 47.4 7.97 8.39 0.923 0.496 0.786 0.922 0.996 0.797
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 47.7 47.7 47.4 0.265 3.30 0.760 0.878 0.770 0.941 0.999 0.872
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 50.1 50.1 47.4 2.66 6.56 0.983 0.675 0.673 0.900 0.858 0.756
ERA5_BARPA [-] 54.3 54.3 47.4 6.87 7.32 0.819 0.546 0.800 0.936 0.998 0.816
ERA5_CCAM [-] 47.7 47.7 47.4 0.268 2.57 0.646 0.877 0.838 0.943 0.999 0.899
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 56.2 56.2 47.4 8.84 9.29 0.986 0.459 0.768 0.910 0.996 0.780
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 54.6 54.6 47.4 7.18 8.01 0.877 0.511 0.770 0.920 0.941 0.783
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 53.3 53.3 47.4 5.86 7.43 0.762 0.598 0.682 0.923 0.998 0.777
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 44.9 44.8 47.4 -2.59 4.20 0.908 0.771 0.763 0.921 0.998 0.843
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 42.9 42.9 47.1 -4.24 6.25 0.902 0.680 0.715 0.919 0.991 0.804
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 41.4
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 48.9 48.1 41.4 6.61 7.22 0.371 0.609 0.803 0.975 0.998 0.838
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 43.8 43.2 41.4 1.73 2.64 0.384 0.862 0.870 0.974 0.995 0.914
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 47.8 47.8 41.5 6.33 7.01 0.399 0.620 0.811 0.973 0.997 0.842
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 49.7 48.8 41.4 7.40 7.82 0.378 0.576 0.821 0.975 0.998 0.838
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 43.9 43.2 41.4 1.78 2.61 0.391 0.855 0.882 0.974 0.993 0.917
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 50.1 50.1 41.5 8.60 9.08 0.426 0.524 0.780 0.971 0.997 0.811
CESM2_BARPA [-] 49.6 48.8 41.4 7.32 7.90 0.465 0.574 0.797 0.968 0.998 0.827
CESM2_CCAM [-] 44.9 44.2 41.4 2.73 3.69 0.606 0.799 0.834 0.959 0.989 0.883
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 49.6 48.7 41.4 7.29 8.11 0.371 0.577 0.766 0.975 0.998 0.816
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 41.4 40.8 41.4 -0.663 2.68 0.377 0.902 0.842 0.975 0.997 0.911
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 40.7 40.7 41.4 -0.645 3.67 0.857 0.839 0.826 0.933 0.977 0.880
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 42.5 41.9 41.4 0.421 2.02 0.302 0.926 0.878 0.980 0.996 0.932
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 42.6 42.6 41.8 0.823 5.21 0.343 0.718 0.820 0.971 0.809 0.828
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 50.1 49.3 41.4 7.86 8.30 0.391 0.557 0.808 0.974 0.998 0.829
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 43.4 42.7 41.4 1.29 2.48 0.384 0.886 0.863 0.974 0.997 0.917
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 47.9 47.6 41.4 6.14 7.62 0.641 0.604 0.759 0.947 0.982 0.810
ERA5_BARPA [-] 48.7 47.9 41.4 6.46 6.97 0.377 0.614 0.826 0.975 0.998 0.848
ERA5_CCAM [-] 43.6 42.9 41.4 1.45 2.34 0.340 0.876 0.888 0.977 0.995 0.925
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 50.4 49.6 41.4 8.12 8.57 0.371 0.543 0.809 0.975 0.998 0.827
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 48.5 47.8 41.4 6.32 7.06 0.455 0.599 0.815 0.970 0.998 0.839
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 47.8 47.0 41.4 5.56 6.72 0.333 0.656 0.766 0.978 0.997 0.832
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 41.5 40.9 41.4 -0.576 2.54 0.372 0.908 0.847 0.975 0.998 0.915
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 38.0 38.0 41.4 -3.34 5.31 0.383 0.769 0.787 0.974 0.986 0.861
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 19.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 32.7 32.0 19.9 12.1 12.9 0.346 0.328 0.643 0.977 0.633 0.645
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 27.4 27.0 19.9 7.08 7.24 0.346 0.517 0.827 0.977 0.981 0.826
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 19.7 19.7 15.7 4.01 4.03 0.00 0.627 0.897 1.00 0.910 0.866
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 33.8 33.1 19.9 13.2 14.1 0.687 0.297 0.614 0.954 0.632 0.622
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 27.2 26.8 19.9 6.84 6.98 0.346 0.528 0.836 0.977 0.977 0.831
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 16.8 16.8 12.9 3.94 3.92 0.00 0.494 0.897 1.00 1.00 0.858
CESM2_BARPA [-] 32.5 31.9 19.9 12.0 12.8 0.346 0.333 0.642 0.977 0.645 0.648
CESM2_CCAM [-] 25.4 25.0 19.9 5.08 5.17 0.346 0.621 0.878 0.977 0.989 0.869
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 32.5 31.9 19.9 12.0 12.6 0.692 0.334 0.674 0.953 0.577 0.642
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 26.4 26.1 19.9 6.21 6.32 0.687 0.561 0.868 0.954 0.958 0.842
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 16.2 16.2 16.8 -0.617 3.47 0.513 0.734 0.732 0.965 0.621 0.757
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 27.1 26.7 19.9 6.82 6.94 0.346 0.530 0.843 0.977 0.951 0.829
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 17.9 17.9 15.0 2.87 2.86 0.00 0.689 0.918 1.00 0.517 0.808
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 34.3 33.7 19.9 13.8 14.7 0.346 0.282 0.613 0.977 0.573 0.611
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 26.5 26.1 19.9 6.23 6.26 0.346 0.561 0.880 0.977 0.934 0.846
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 16.9 17.3 19.9 -2.63 4.59 0.346 0.743 0.770 0.977 0.827 0.817
ERA5_BARPA [-] 32.7 32.2 19.9 12.3 13.0 0.346 0.325 0.644 0.977 0.588 0.635
ERA5_CCAM [-] 27.2 26.9 19.9 6.97 7.00 0.346 0.524 0.870 0.977 0.908 0.830
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 33.4 32.7 19.9 12.8 13.7 0.687 0.309 0.624 0.954 0.610 0.624
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 28.3 23.0 19.9 3.04 3.68 0.346 0.760 0.825 0.977 0.572 0.792
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 32.2 31.6 19.9 11.7 12.4 0.687 0.342 0.663 0.954 0.599 0.644
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 26.3 25.9 19.9 6.03 6.15 0.687 0.570 0.846 0.954 0.986 0.840
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 19.1 19.1 16.8 2.28 2.95 1.03 0.750 0.820 0.930 0.225 0.709
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 13.3
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 30.4 25.9 13.3 12.6 14.0 0.258 0.183 0.437 0.983 0.729 0.554
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 23.2 20.1 13.3 6.90 7.42 0.521 0.396 0.683 0.965 0.860 0.717
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 14.5 14.5 12.9 1.66 1.71 0.00 0.771 0.904 1.00 1.00 0.916
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 31.2 26.6 13.3 13.3 14.9 0.513 0.167 0.402 0.966 0.703 0.528
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 21.7 18.7 13.3 5.44 5.99 0.513 0.484 0.709 0.966 0.863 0.746
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 19.5 19.5 14.9 4.58 4.90 0.00 0.555 0.770 1.00 0.00126 0.619
CESM2_BARPA [-] 30.4 25.8 13.3 12.6 14.2 0.521 0.184 0.415 0.965 0.719 0.540
CESM2_CCAM [-] 21.0 18.2 13.3 4.98 5.48 0.521 0.511 0.727 0.965 0.913 0.768
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 30.5 25.9 13.3 12.7 14.1 0.521 0.183 0.437 0.965 0.710 0.546
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 23.3 20.2 13.3 6.92 7.23 0.254 0.396 0.737 0.983 0.865 0.743
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 14.2 14.2 13.2 0.980 2.43 0.689 0.830 0.808 0.954 0.740 0.828
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 22.2 19.1 13.3 5.88 6.27 0.521 0.456 0.730 0.965 0.855 0.747
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 16.6 16.6 13.2 3.36 3.64 0.347 0.597 0.788 0.977 0.992 0.828
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 32.8 28.0 13.3 14.8 16.3 0.513 0.138 0.385 0.966 0.677 0.510
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 22.7 19.8 13.3 6.51 6.99 0.513 0.417 0.688 0.966 0.885 0.729
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 17.5 16.8 13.3 3.52 3.69 0.521 0.623 0.828 0.965 0.991 0.847
ERA5_BARPA [-] 31.2 26.6 13.3 13.3 14.7 0.517 0.168 0.430 0.965 0.708 0.540
ERA5_CCAM [-] 23.7 20.5 13.3 7.26 7.60 0.513 0.378 0.716 0.966 0.849 0.725
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 30.4 25.7 13.3 12.5 14.0 0.513 0.188 0.419 0.966 0.706 0.539
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 18.2 17.8 13.3 4.55 6.10 0.521 0.590 0.594 0.965 0.741 0.697
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 30.6 26.1 13.3 12.8 14.1 0.513 0.179 0.445 0.966 0.734 0.554
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 22.3 19.4 13.3 6.11 6.71 0.513 0.438 0.677 0.966 0.895 0.731
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 15.9 15.9 13.2 2.73 3.02 0.339 0.646 0.793 0.977 0.964 0.835
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 21.0
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 34.4 32.0 21.0 11.0 11.9 0.297 0.281 0.566 0.980 0.965 0.672
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 29.7 28.0 21.0 6.97 7.20 0.147 0.441 0.776 0.990 0.997 0.796
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 23.1 23.1 18.8 4.28 4.50 0.696 0.556 0.807 0.953 0.748 0.774
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 35.3 32.9 21.0 11.9 12.9 0.737 0.251 0.555 0.950 0.960 0.654
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 29.2 27.7 21.0 6.68 6.86 0.297 0.457 0.802 0.980 0.994 0.807
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 24.1 24.1 20.3 3.81 4.32 1.03 0.607 0.764 0.931 0.988 0.811
CESM2_BARPA [-] 33.7 31.5 21.0 10.6 11.4 0.589 0.294 0.590 0.960 0.958 0.679
CESM2_CCAM [-] 29.2 27.5 21.0 6.49 6.63 0.444 0.469 0.825 0.970 0.994 0.817
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 33.9 31.6 21.0 10.7 11.5 0.442 0.291 0.592 0.970 0.949 0.679
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 27.7 26.2 21.0 5.20 5.38 0.591 0.542 0.854 0.960 0.987 0.839
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 19.0 19.0 20.1 -1.11 3.03 0.347 0.834 0.716 0.977 0.937 0.836
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 28.8 27.1 21.0 6.13 6.37 0.737 0.487 0.788 0.950 0.995 0.802
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 20.1 20.1 21.0 -0.903 1.79 0.693 0.906 0.848 0.953 0.924 0.896
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 35.5 33.1 21.0 12.1 13.1 0.737 0.246 0.540 0.950 0.956 0.646
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 28.7 27.0 21.0 6.02 6.18 0.737 0.493 0.815 0.950 0.998 0.814
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 21.4 21.0 21.0 0.0569 4.04 1.32 0.705 0.768 0.861 0.701 0.761
ERA5_BARPA [-] 34.0 31.7 21.0 10.7 11.6 0.589 0.289 0.580 0.960 0.964 0.675
ERA5_CCAM [-] 28.7 27.0 21.0 6.06 6.19 0.591 0.490 0.838 0.960 0.998 0.825
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 35.5 32.9 21.0 11.9 13.0 0.444 0.252 0.534 0.970 0.909 0.640
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 27.6 24.0 21.0 3.03 4.07 0.589 0.698 0.771 0.960 0.885 0.817
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 33.3 31.0 21.0 10.0 10.9 0.444 0.313 0.584 0.970 0.976 0.685
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 28.1 26.5 21.0 5.49 5.76 0.591 0.523 0.795 0.960 0.998 0.814
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 20.9 20.9 20.1 0.842 2.60 0.518 0.826 0.788 0.965 0.981 0.870
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 28.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 35.7 33.5 28.9 4.63 5.06 0.00 0.723 0.868 1.00 0.775 0.847
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 31.2 29.1 28.9 0.252 2.63 0.341 0.918 0.847 0.977 0.947 0.907
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 20.2 20.2 24.5 -4.27 5.58 0.00 0.689 0.740 1.00 0.583 0.751
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 36.8 34.5 28.9 5.68 5.95 0.519 0.678 0.860 0.965 0.750 0.823
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 30.9 28.9 28.9 0.0914 2.51 0.341 0.908 0.862 0.977 0.903 0.903
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 28.0 28.0 30.5 -2.52 3.28 0.00 0.840 0.878 1.00 0.0740 0.734
CESM2_BARPA [-] 35.1 33.1 28.9 4.21 4.67 0.00 0.740 0.874 1.00 0.781 0.854
CESM2_CCAM [-] 29.7 27.9 28.9 -0.983 3.32 0.341 0.875 0.816 0.977 0.944 0.885
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 35.4 33.3 28.9 4.49 5.01 0.346 0.727 0.862 0.977 0.764 0.838
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 31.2 29.1 28.9 0.214 2.64 0.341 0.906 0.844 0.977 0.913 0.897
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 23.7 23.7 27.8 -4.07 5.69 0.00 0.726 0.740 1.00 1.00 0.841
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 30.7 28.7 28.9 -0.180 2.64 0.344 0.913 0.849 0.977 0.908 0.899
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 18.7 18.7 22.7 -3.97 5.13 0.00 0.690 0.749 1.00 1.00 0.838
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 37.4 35.1 28.9 6.25 6.43 0.692 0.648 0.868 0.953 0.752 0.818
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 31.1 29.0 28.9 0.170 2.85 0.514 0.909 0.833 0.965 0.912 0.891
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 35.5 35.3 28.9 6.47 6.56 0.692 0.613 0.871 0.953 0.997 0.861
ERA5_BARPA [-] 35.6 33.4 28.9 4.60 5.02 0.171 0.725 0.872 0.989 0.771 0.846
ERA5_CCAM [-] 31.2 29.1 28.9 0.221 2.66 0.514 0.905 0.850 0.965 0.903 0.894
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 35.7 33.6 28.9 4.74 5.22 0.692 0.716 0.863 0.953 0.755 0.830
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 34.6 30.5 28.9 1.67 5.40 0.692 0.722 0.786 0.953 0.592 0.768
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 35.0 32.9 28.9 4.09 4.62 0.341 0.746 0.866 0.977 0.796 0.850
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 30.3 28.3 28.9 -0.563 3.16 0.514 0.910 0.812 0.965 0.941 0.888
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 25.2 25.2 27.8 -2.58 5.28 0.788 0.826 0.711 0.949 0.951 0.830
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 34.6
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 44.1 37.8 34.6 3.23 4.75 0.722 0.762 0.871 0.951 0.882 0.868
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 39.5 34.6 34.6 -0.0399 3.04 0.721 0.894 0.834 0.952 0.992 0.901
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 32.5 32.5 30.2 2.28 5.12 0.00 0.668 0.869 1.00 0.945 0.870
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 44.9 38.5 34.6 3.94 5.15 0.516 0.745 0.877 0.965 0.872 0.867
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 39.0 34.0 34.6 -0.567 3.27 0.413 0.912 0.819 0.972 0.985 0.901
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 40.8 40.8 37.8 3.05 4.10 0.349 0.826 0.860 0.976 0.959 0.896
CESM2_BARPA [-] 43.8 37.6 34.6 2.99 4.67 0.312 0.765 0.867 0.979 0.875 0.871
CESM2_CCAM [-] 39.5 34.4 34.6 -0.147 3.21 0.618 0.889 0.833 0.958 0.978 0.898
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 44.2 37.9 34.6 3.28 4.90 0.621 0.758 0.858 0.958 0.870 0.860
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 37.7 33.0 34.6 -1.57 4.11 0.722 0.900 0.776 0.951 0.998 0.880
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 30.7 30.7 36.2 -5.51 7.47 0.442 0.695 0.732 0.970 0.913 0.808
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 37.5 32.8 34.6 -1.77 3.79 0.618 0.881 0.804 0.958 0.993 0.888
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 35.0 35.0 35.9 -0.881 3.53 0.410 0.819 0.887 0.972 0.840 0.881
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 45.6 39.2 34.6 4.61 5.60 0.621 0.726 0.875 0.958 0.868 0.861
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 38.3 33.5 34.6 -1.07 3.91 0.516 0.908 0.785 0.965 0.991 0.887
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 34.9 34.5 34.6 -0.0626 5.39 0.621 0.743 0.819 0.958 0.976 0.863
ERA5_BARPA [-] 43.7 37.5 34.6 2.90 4.57 0.723 0.770 0.874 0.951 0.886 0.871
ERA5_CCAM [-] 38.5 33.7 34.6 -0.912 3.45 0.516 0.913 0.808 0.965 0.990 0.897
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 44.6 38.2 34.6 3.61 5.14 0.621 0.745 0.871 0.958 0.861 0.861
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 43.9 35.5 34.6 0.866 3.42 0.621 0.871 0.828 0.958 0.941 0.885
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 42.9 36.9 34.6 2.26 4.40 0.413 0.790 0.841 0.972 0.900 0.869
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 37.3 32.6 34.6 -1.97 3.41 0.517 0.874 0.833 0.965 0.997 0.900
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 30.3 30.3 36.2 -5.90 8.19 0.151 0.687 0.719 0.990 0.877 0.798
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 37.9
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 45.9 45.3 37.9 7.45 8.03 0.246 0.600 0.796 0.983 0.956 0.827
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 40.6 40.7 37.9 2.79 3.51 0.211 0.824 0.865 0.986 0.993 0.907
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 39.8 39.8 36.2 3.59 4.63 0.0773 0.779 0.847 0.995 0.995 0.892
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 47.1 46.5 37.9 8.61 8.95 0.246 0.556 0.814 0.983 0.961 0.826
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 40.0 40.1 37.9 2.17 3.11 0.246 0.855 0.872 0.983 0.989 0.914
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 39.2 39.2 35.4 3.76 6.34 0.0778 0.711 0.807 0.995 0.995 0.863
CESM2_BARPA [-] 46.2 45.7 37.9 7.78 8.17 0.531 0.589 0.813 0.964 0.981 0.832
CESM2_CCAM [-] 39.5 39.6 37.9 1.76 2.71 0.567 0.877 0.871 0.962 0.997 0.916
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 46.3 45.7 37.9 7.81 8.04 0.141 0.588 0.839 0.991 0.981 0.847
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 38.5 38.5 37.9 0.659 3.53 0.247 0.909 0.823 0.983 0.978 0.903
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 34.6 34.6 35.9 -1.25 3.87 0.195 0.829 0.825 0.987 0.992 0.892
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 38.1 38.2 37.9 0.300 3.14 0.142 0.905 0.843 0.990 0.963 0.909
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 35.5 35.5 34.6 0.855 4.63 0.152 0.762 0.819 0.990 0.993 0.877
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 46.8 46.2 37.9 8.36 8.76 0.246 0.565 0.809 0.983 0.950 0.823
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 39.1 39.2 37.9 1.33 3.13 0.142 0.882 0.854 0.990 0.968 0.910
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 41.8 41.7 37.9 3.82 7.13 0.246 0.675 0.786 0.983 0.912 0.829
ERA5_BARPA [-] 45.8 45.2 37.9 7.36 7.56 0.212 0.605 0.850 0.986 0.968 0.852
ERA5_CCAM [-] 39.6 39.7 37.9 1.78 3.11 0.246 0.869 0.865 0.983 0.978 0.912
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 46.8 46.2 37.9 8.35 8.81 0.246 0.566 0.798 0.983 0.971 0.823
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 46.2 43.9 37.9 5.99 7.06 0.246 0.665 0.802 0.983 0.960 0.842
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 45.2 44.6 37.9 6.73 7.23 0.246 0.631 0.815 0.983 0.965 0.842
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 38.8 38.9 37.9 1.03 2.82 0.246 0.905 0.864 0.983 0.980 0.919
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 33.8 33.8 35.9 -2.04 4.81 0.558 0.819 0.794 0.962 0.994 0.873
Download Data
Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]
Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]
Bias [W m-2]
RMSE [W m-2]
Phase Shift [months]
Bias Score [1]
RMSE Score [1]
Seasonal Cycle Score [1]
Spatial Distribution Score [1]
Overall Score [1]
Benchmark [-] 28.0
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA [-] 41.5 37.6 28.0 9.51 9.87 0.614 0.266 0.703 0.959 0.954 0.717
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM [-] 29.8 27.6 28.0 -0.474 3.37 0.614 0.709 0.694 0.959 0.861 0.784
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6 [-] 26.8 26.8 24.5 2.31 4.17 1.02 0.535 0.715 0.933 0.719 0.723
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA [-] 41.5 37.6 28.0 9.54 9.82 0.614 0.264 0.727 0.959 0.954 0.726
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM [-] 29.0 26.9 28.0 -1.11 3.25 0.614 0.696 0.725 0.959 0.820 0.785
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6 [-] 30.0 30.0 23.6 6.41 7.35 1.02 0.365 0.544 0.933 0.946 0.666
CESM2_BARPA [-] 42.4 38.2 28.0 10.2 10.5 0.512 0.243 0.724 0.966 0.963 0.724
CESM2_CCAM [-] 29.7 27.5 28.0 -0.595 3.35 0.614 0.689 0.717 0.959 0.800 0.776
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA [-] 42.6 38.5 28.0 10.4 10.7 0.303 0.232 0.731 0.980 0.963 0.727
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM [-] 29.4 27.3 28.0 -0.735 3.40 0.102 0.701 0.700 0.993 0.810 0.781
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6 [-] 30.4 30.4 26.9 3.50 4.88 0.680 0.577 0.636 0.955 0.968 0.754
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM [-] 30.5 28.3 28.0 0.263 3.23 0.813 0.739 0.697 0.946 0.858 0.788
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6 [-] 29.5 29.5 24.8 4.68 5.06 0.169 0.394 0.696 0.989 0.969 0.749
EC-Earth3_BARPA [-] 41.9 37.8 28.0 9.72 9.92 0.306 0.257 0.771 0.980 0.956 0.747
EC-Earth3_CCAM [-] 28.3 26.2 28.0 -1.86 3.90 0.307 0.686 0.668 0.980 0.803 0.761
EC-Earth3_CMIP6 [-] 31.6 29.4 28.0 1.33 5.17 0.512 0.542 0.676 0.966 0.991 0.770
ERA5_BARPA [-] 41.0 37.1 28.0 9.07 9.41 0.511 0.281 0.727 0.966 0.942 0.729
ERA5_CCAM [-] 28.4 26.3 28.0 -1.71 3.65 0.304 0.688 0.696 0.980 0.784 0.769
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA [-] 42.6 38.6 28.0 10.6 10.8 0.711 0.227 0.741 0.953 0.969 0.726
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6 [-] 42.5 45.0 28.0 17.0 17.2 0.713 0.144 0.628 0.953 0.965 0.663
NorESM2-MM_BARPA [-] 40.6 36.6 28.0 8.60 9.08 0.199 0.302 0.687 0.987 0.940 0.720
NorESM2-MM_CCAM [-] 26.3 24.4 28.0 -3.63 5.09 0.304 0.597 0.636 0.980 0.701 0.710
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6 [-] 28.5 28.5 26.9 1.57 3.37 0.904 0.651 0.748 0.940 0.997 0.817

Temporally integrated period mean

BENCHMARK MEAN
Data not available
Data not available
MODEL MEAN
Data not available
BIAS
Data not available
BIAS SCORE
Data not available
Data not available
RMSE
Data not available
RMSE SCORE
Data not available
Data not available
BENCHMARK MAX MONTH
Data not available
Data not available
MODEL MAX MONTH
Data not available
Data not available
DIFFERENCE IN MAX MONTH
Data not available
SEASONAL CYCLE SCORE
Data not available

SPATIAL TAYLOR DIAGRAM
Data not available
MODEL COLORS
Data not available

Spatially integrated regional mean

MODEL COLORS
Data not available
REGIONAL MEAN
Data not available
ANNUAL CYCLE
Data not available
MONTHLY ANOMALY
Data not available
ANNUAL CYCLE
Data not available

All Models

Benchmark
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-CM2_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
ACCESS-ESM1-5_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
CESM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
CESM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CMCC-ESM2_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
CNRM-ESM2-1_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
CNRM-ESM2-1_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
EC-Earth3_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
ERA5_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
ERA5_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
MPI-ESM1-2-HR_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_BARPA
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_CCAM
Data not available
Data not available
NorESM2-MM_CMIP6
Data not available
Data not available

Data Information

  Title:
CERES EBAF TOA and Surface Fluxes

  Institutions:
NASA Langley Research Center

  Source:
Monthly mean surface fluxes calculated by a radiative transfer model and constrained by the combined Terra and Aqua SSF1deg measurements

  History:
2019-06-25: downloaded source from https://ceres.larc.nasa.gov/products-info.php?product=EBAF
2019-08-13: converted to netCDF with https://github.com/mmu2019/Datasets/blob/master/read-rsus-ceres.py

  References:
Loeb, N.G., D.R. Doelling, H. Wang, W. Su, C. Nguyen, J.G. Corbett, L. Liang, C. Mitrescu, F.G. Rose, and S. Kato (2018), Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) Top-of-Atmosphere (TOA) Edition-4.0 Data Product, Journal of Climate, 31(2), 895-918, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0208.1

Kato, S., F. G. Rose, D. A. Rutan, T. E. Thorsen, N. G. Loeb, D. R. Doelling, X. Huang, W. L. Smith, W. Su, and S.-H. Ham (2018), Surface irradiances of Edition 4.0 Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) data product, Journal of Climate, 31, 4501-4527, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0523.1

  Comments:
time_period: 2000-01 through 2018-12
original_temporal_resolution: monthly
original_spatial_resolution: 1 degree
original_units: W m-2
final_temporal_resolution: monthly
final_spatial_resolution: 0.5 degree
final_units: W m-2

  Convention:
CF-1.7